StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Statistical Differences Related to Migration Problems and Drug Use - Book Report/Review Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Statistical Differences Related to Migration Problems and Drug Use" tells that reading this research paper gives a greater understanding of the homeless and the interrelationship with migratory factors associated with drug/alcohol and mental health problems…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97% of users find it useful
Statistical Differences Related to Migration Problems and Drug Use
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Statistical Differences Related to Migration Problems and Drug Use"

Running Head: EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE AND CRITICAL AWARENESS Evidence Based Practice and critical Awareness of the of the institution] Evidence Based Practice and critical Awareness Tompkins, C. Wright, N. Sheard, L. Associations between migrancy, health and homelessness: a cross-sectional study. Health & Social Care in the Community. 2003. Sep. 11(5). p446-52. Abstract/aims of study Tompkins et al (2003) aims are as stated in the title, they sought to identify statistical differences between problematic drug/alcohol use, and mental health problems (independent variables) associated with migrancy patterns (dependent variables). They state that the patterns of migrancy are different for problematic alcohol users and problematic drug users, with no significant difference for the migration for mental health (p. 446). The objective of the study was to help in the improvement of planning for appropriate health and social needs for these varying groups. Precise aims and criteria are set out in the abstract with 4 key factors: Place of birth (PLOB), drugs, alcohol and mental health. Whilst looking at interactions of factors and an overview of their interdependence. Literature review. The primary purpose for reviewing literature is to gain a broad background and understanding of information that is available to support the study intention (Burns & Grove 1999). The authors identify the limits of defining homelessness in its broadest sense (p.446) and are not limited to those in priority needs, as set out in the homeless act (2002). They look at migrancy as opposed to mobility and the literature review gives a comprehensive account of homelessness and differentiates between aspects of migrancy to that of mobility. It looks at the difficulties of providing continuity of social and primary healthcare with these complex groups. and provides the background for which the present study is based. They also give a clear definition of homeless, along with supportive material, Shelter, Royal College of Practioners (RCP), HMSO etc with variable statistics and key journal publications,. with the majority of the material referred to being within ten years of the paper being published. Good use of comparative illustrations, with clear definitions of the terms they are using e.g. migrancy including acknowledging the limitations of this article and that limited research has been done between health status and migrancy in homeless populations (p.447) They state how this article fits into a wider understanding of the interrelationships of the key factors and why this study is important. . From this Tompkins et al provides the rationale for the study with the need to identify migrancy behaviour from place of birth (PLOB) and measured. In this context the authors are concerned with identifying PLOB as an important aspect of information regarding migratory behaviour that can be readily elicited and recorded in a primary care consultation, with overall findings leading to a more informed health policy, and improved health/social services for homeless people. (447) Methodology As no hypothesis was stated the aims influenced the research method and with this type of study, an appropriate research method was used (cross-sectional design) it allowed the researchers the flexibility of collecting data from the different groups at various stages of their homelessness. It also allows a comparatively large amount of information to be collected over a relatively short space of time, with lower financial implications (Parahoo 1997). It focuses on numerical data and is a valid tool for the proposed study undertaken. The inclusion criteria was a random sample of 522 consecutive new homeless patients (over16yrs) registering to a health centre for homeless people in Leeds, over 18 months period with PLOB recorded on a Computerised Medical information System. The sample size being large enough over the time period for any sampling error to decrease over time, with any differences existing between the groups detected statistically. (Tab 3) They addressed the ethical nature of this means of data collection by taking advice from the local research ethics committee; they gain approval by the fact that the data was anonymous and not of a sensitive nature. Although advice was taken from the ethical committee there was no clear statement about gaining informed consent from the client groups. The diagnostic categories' were based on self reporting in the consultation records, although a detailed description of the questions asked are not given, and how sensitive a manor was the self reporting based To signify the value for this type of data collection, they used the Chi- squared test, which allows them to see if the results of the experiment differ from those expected from the original aim by random chance. With low P values in all categories their data matched the expected findings, and with a t-test for the difference between age as a continuous variable (Ogiers 2002) The reader is informed how statistics are allowed for and validity on measures used (p448) Table 1 gives the variables, numbers and percentages (descriptive statistics), but does not state why there are more men than women in the survey. Also there is a precise breakdown of ages but not by gender. They state that heroin is the main problematic drug with cannabis second but their percentage figures are different (p449) Table 2 (Age and sex statistics by health factors) give a breakdown of figures into precise groupings, plus allowing for variables and controls. Table 3 (Place of birth by patient characteristics) as with the previous points, showing breakdown of factors and their interrelationships. There is inadequate awareness of the link between conflicting health problems and migrancy of homeless people. The present cross-sectional study sought to measures the area of migrancy of homeless people from their place of birth (PLOB) and appraise whether a history of challenging drug use, alcohol misuse or enduring mental health problems were linked with migrancy from their PLOB. The research was carried out at an inner- city health centre for the homeless in the north of England. Place of birth was shaped as an entry on the computerized registration proceedings. The PLOB was composed and confirmation for each homeless person record with the service over the study period. Information was also taken regarding analysis of problematic banned drug use, problematic alcohol use and continuing mental health problems for each homeless person. The study recognized statistically important dissimilarity for the migration of homeless people from their PLOB for age, challenging drug use and problematic alcohol use. Problematic alcohol use is separately associated with an improved likelihood of migration from the PLOB. On the other hand, a history of illicit drug use is connected with a reduced option of migration from the PLOB when analyzing primary healthcare services. There was no important variation for resettlement from the PLOB for mental health. Not all homeless people migrate from their PLOB and health harms of drug use, mental health or alcohol use are separately associated with different outline of migration. Understanding the migrancy of homeless people is significant when preparation and objective suitable health and social services to address their unstable health, social and mental needs. This research needed to quantify the level of migrancy of homeless people from their place of birth and assess whether a history of challenging drug abuse, alcohol abuse or continuing mental health problems were associated with migration. The research recognized statistically important differences for migrancy in relation to age, drug use (lower) and alcohol use (higher). Yet there was no important difference in relation to mental health. Not all dispossessed people travel from place of birth and health harms were separately related with different patterns of immigration. Understanding migrancy of homeless people was significant to local preparation and objective of health and social services This work regularly composed the place of birth for each homeless person record with the service. Information was also extracted concerning diagnoses of problematic illegal drug use, problematic alcohol use and continuing mental health problems. Statistically important differences were recognized for the migration of homeless people from their POB for age, problematic drug use and challenging alcohol use. Understanding the migrancy of homeless people is essential when planning and targeting suitable health and social services to address their unstable health, social and psychological needs. The authors make points that health needs are based upon patient's ideas rather than diagnosed by professionals and points out possibly criticism e.g. study only looks at single homeless in urban locations, therefore only limited comparisons can be made. They state (p450) the major methodological limitations being the social desirability bias, but validates this with the bias being under-reported (false negative) rather than over-reported (false positive) Perhaps a statistician would know if they overcome this. Results/ findings Parts of the research are validated by other authors' findings with references given. However no study of a similar nature towards migrancy had been done prior to this study, so it cannot be judged against similar findings. It says ultimately that there is a need for greater communication between differing agencies, and the implementation of appropriate information technology (electronic transfer of records) for the availability of patients' records. Tompkins stated the difficulty in verifying alcohol dependency which could question the validity, accuracy and possibly bias due to the subject being alcohol misuse; shame guilt and stigma may inhibit a person from disclosing the reality of their situation. Asking this client group to divulge information that is deemed socially unpopular may have a diverse effect on their future housing requirements (Polit 1997). Conclusion The article achieves what it sets out to do from its initial aim, and identifies the priority of homeless people (as defined by the authors for this research) with problematic alcohol use having less social support than substance and mental health homeless. Tompkins et al identifies that more research is needed on the relationship of migrancy and other key factors and states precise recommendations for improved care in light of this study. (p452) The article raises question with their research findings that are relevant, and their potential for implications The research methods that the authors have used for their study intention appear to meet the criteria required within the process of quantitative research. However could this paper have been influenced by the RCGPs concerns for a more informed health policy via development of information technology support, and electronic transfer of patient's records as the research falls in line with their statements Subsequently, could this research be for a future government analysis on housing, social and psychological needs and will it be a part of a government publication on the issues raised Implications for practice This paper could have some implication for practice as previously out- lined. The use of electronic resources for GPs who generally are the first point of contact, could use this system to improve his/her communications with the array of social networks targeted at these specific groups. As to whether it would ultimately be a direct benefit to the particular client groups would have to be seen. However it would allow Health authorities in planning appropriate services. From reading this research paper it gives a greater understanding of homeless and the interrelationship with migratory factors associated with drug/alcohol and mental health problems. It gives the reader more confidence to be able to read, understand and appraise further nursing research, to work positively towards enhancing the quality of care given to patients, and to find and apply evidence to enlighten their practice in the present NHS climate. Furthermore rresearch within nursing practice allows for the opportunity for medical professionals to ask questions about their practice and seek answers by producing data that can encourage decision-making (Crookes & Davis 1999). Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Evidence Based Practice and critical Awareness Book Report/Review”, n.d.)
Evidence Based Practice and critical Awareness Book Report/Review. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/sociology/1524271-evidence-based-practice-and-critical-awareness
(Evidence Based Practice and Critical Awareness Book Report/Review)
Evidence Based Practice and Critical Awareness Book Report/Review. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1524271-evidence-based-practice-and-critical-awareness.
“Evidence Based Practice and Critical Awareness Book Report/Review”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/sociology/1524271-evidence-based-practice-and-critical-awareness.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Statistical Differences Related to Migration Problems and Drug Use

Illegal Immigration in the United States

Chain migration is one of the most visible aspects of illegal migrations in the U.... Chain migration occurs where illegal immigrants attract relatives, friends, or associates from their countries of origin to join them once they have settled in the states.... Efforts to contain illegal immigration have often been caught up in differences conditioned by political competition, private interests, and lobby pressure (Kenney and Kwao 50)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Research Paper

Nature of Post-War Drug Use

hellip; drug use is universal.... round the world, approximately 15% of the population older than 18 years of age is considered to have serious drug use problems.... As an example, approximately 33%of the populations of the United States and Australia, and 10% to 20% of the population of different European countries, report lifetime use of marijuana.... % of the world's population use marijuana so regularly as to incur recognizable consequences (Adams, Gfoerer, & Rouse, 1989, 14-20)....
17 Pages (4250 words) Essay

The role of race in drug prosecutions

he Paper concludes that given that it is true that the majority of offenders are Asian and are perceived as a threat to public order and drug prevention they should be understood for their relative economic and social conditions.... he overall aim of this study is to provide an understanding of how violence and drug crime has been understood from the perspective of race particularly for South Asian offenders in England.... The Study is original in the sense that few if any of the members of the academia like to venture… My study aims to discover why South Asian minorities are suffering today from racial bias by the general public as well as the police force in drug related crimes will explore the legal, moral nd historical premises behind all the increasing tendency of South Asian men to be found in Britain's prisons....
30 Pages (7500 words) Essay

Emigrant and Immigration: How does immigration affect the US economy

The problems in information for the migrants might be more complicated than the actual perceived levels both in terms of distance and in cross culture between the host and the source country (Bijwaard, 2008, p.... The different countries in Western Europe experienced considerable number of migration especially immigration flows from Asia and other regions of the world over the years and this had led to changes in the emigration to immigration policies of the countries....
15 Pages (3750 words) Research Paper

A Comparative Analysis of Juvenile Crime In The United States And Japan

Reports of violence, sexual deviation, theft, and drugs reflect social problems that are embedded in the youth.... In conclusion, the results of the The primary purpose of the research is to ascertain differences and similarities in rates of juvenile offender recidivism in Japan and the United States.... A statistical method is used to compare samples from the United States and Japanese… The data samples are compiled of figures from the online databases of the Bureau of Justice Statistics, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention, and the National Criminal Justice Reference Service....
55 Pages (13750 words) Thesis

Asians in New Zealand: Migration, Mental Health, and Service Use

This research proposal "Asians in New Zealand: Migration, Mental Health, and Service use" describes the state of mental health of the Asian immigrants in New Zealand.... As this is so, authorities from national to local levels in New Zealand continue to enact and collaborate with appropriate organizations in the private sector in imposing policies that can increase awareness, prevent, treat and rehabilitate individuals with mental illness as consequences of mental health can affect not only the lives of the mentally ill but also the community around them; creating problems in social, cultural, and economic status and development of the wider population....
20 Pages (5000 words) Research Proposal

Obstacles in the Path toward a Comprehensive Immigration Reform

There is no doubt that the current immigration crisis is related to the presence of several million unauthorized Hispanics who reside in the United States.... This paper ”Obstacles in the Path toward a Comprehensive Immigration Reform” illustrates the activities of past and present administrations in point of the immigration reform and the dispute on this problem by analyzing some of the most convincing supporters and opponents' arguments....
19 Pages (4750 words) Research Paper

The Relation between the USA International Relations, Immigration and the Economy

The social problems that accompany the illegal immigrants influence the nature in which decision is made by both the employers and the administration.... The most constant factor of the migration is the manner in which the illegal immigrants move into a given country despite the existing differences between the countries of origin with the United State of America.... The determining factor, in this case, is less of the political differences and similarity but rather more of available resources and the friendly nature of the counter....
10 Pages (2500 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us