StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Function of Property Law and Effects of Exclusion - Case Study Example

Summary
"The Function of Property Law and Effects of Exclusion" paper reviews controversies that surround the understanding of property law, especially in new contexts. It is noted; from the case, studies presented that even lawyers struggle to apply property concepts in different dimensions and contexts…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER96.6% of users find it useful

Extract of sample "The Function of Property Law and Effects of Exclusion"

Table of Contents 1.0.Introduction 2 2.0.The Function of Property Law and Effects of Exclusion 3 3.0.Case of human embryo 4 4.0.Case of human tissue 5 5.0.Conclusion 8 6.0.Bibliography 9 1.0. Introduction What Kevin Gray finds is that when “property” is subjected to close analysis the concept vanishes into thin air. While this report finds the statement to be considerate in light of the complexities of the law, further reality is, with regard to schema of significant legal subject areas, property law is the overall mechanism by which the very same law guides the interactions between ‘property’ and people. What Kevin Gray seems to be suggesting generates a torrent of unique and incompatible responses. Although this report finds that the treatment of well-established underpinnings of ‘property’ can be understood from different judicial decisions in Australia and specifically, Western Australian legislation, difficulties still arise in unfamiliar and new contexts. A clear case is where there are new potentialities of separation1 brought by technological change, new sources of wealth2 as well as possibilities of exclusion. In such situations, it is essential to make a decision on how new properties will be treated---as such Kevin Gray believes property will vanish into thin air if it fails to be an object of property rights. It is from this basis that the report supports the argument postulated by Kevin Gray with regard to multifaceted approaches to what understanding property in Australian Law. 2.0. The Function of Property Law and Effects of Exclusion The premise here is that it is from the very same law that one can identify who is subject to which legal relations when it comes to a property and how these can be enforced.3 On the other hand, it is on the premise of the very same law that some properties fall entirely or partly outside the realm of it (property law), only sui generis (specified tailored) rules are able to perform the same function. As noted in recent judgement4, in absence of what courts can determine as sufficient sui generis strategy, a failure to apply property law generate wrongs that come without remedies as well as pervasive uncertainty. The concept of exclusion that makes the aspect of property complicated is that there is a choice between allowing general rules of property law to take its operation and attempting to impose a sui generis. As such, regime needs to take account of the possibility of incompleteness, redundancy and delay in the involved in the former.5 3.0. Case of human embryo To coceptualise the position held above, this report compares what property law in Australia and United States understand with regard to embryos. To begin with, treatment of human embryo has been regarded as inappropriate.6 Separately, it is held in United States that embryos are neither property nor persons but are entitled to special treatment and respect.7 The point of concurrence with Kevin Gray is that if such is the stance then interactions with embryo must be regulated on the premise of sui generis.8 A more complicated case was the case in California involving Moore v Regents of the University of California (Moore)9 While Moore maintained that the spleen was his property; California Supreme Court rejected this claim only allowing a breach of fiduciary duty (Roderick et al. 2002). 4.0. Case of human tissue This case disappears in a thin air when compared with Australian property law that when there is tissue from a corpse, there is no property entitled10 (of course this has varying degree in United States). Contrariwise, considering Roche v Dougla11s in Australia, a Master of the Supreme Court of Western Australia made an order that certain parts of a tissue should be tested to be ‘property’. The fact that the court ruled out the possibility of all tissues being ‘property’ underscores the verdict given by Kevin Gray. Basing on the function of property law and effects of exclusion as connected with embryo and tissue, the understanding is that Australian Property Law is not clear on what a property is. As such, Roger (2000) notes that object of property has significant practical implications when given myriad contexts. In some jurisdictions as well as cases, other legal doctrines or sui generis rule can fulfill similar objectives to property law.12 The realization thus far is to understand what property means in light of Australian property law since the basis of the very same law has been disputed by Kevin Gray and even supported by relevant cases. What Australian law contains as definition come in one of the many forms. One of such is the insistence that rights owed to individuals can fall into some recognized category (such categories has been viewed differently in category tests) such as the category test in Ainsworth test (National Provincial Bank Ltd v Ainsworth)13 This is the same premise when it comes to financial matters and excludability test is applied. Dealing with recognized category test, it has been understood that what is deemed as property under Australian property law diminishes as soon as a claim is instigated. As such, the meaning of a property constantly lacks meaning. Australian case involving Victoria Park Racing and Recreation Grounds Co Ltd v Taylor is a good example.14 In their judgement, the High Court opined that there was no property in a spectacle. When such premise is to be held then how else would a race conducted on a person’s land cease to be the land of the person? It even appalled that Dixon J believed that only rights in previously recognized categories stand to be the property.15 As it was captured in the introduction, a property lacks meaning and vanishes in the thin air if property law does not recognize it in a new environment. In fact, Kevin Gray believes that these properties vanish into a thin air because the law allows such properties to be limited to previously recognized categories thus affecting the scope of such categories. One High Court judge recently criticized the conclusion made concerning Victoria Park Racing16 Another test that has been construed shallowly is he Ainswort. To understand how this point, this report revisits statement made by Lord Wilberforce. He stated: Before a right or an interest can be admitted into the category of property, or of a right affecting property, it must be definable, identifiable by third parties, capable in its nature of assumption by third parties, and have some degree of permanence or stability.17 Though it was in a different jurisdiction, it has been adopted in Western Australia to understand what a property is.18 As understoond in Australia, it remains that property only contingently belong to a given person. Again, since the requirement has been falling short of alienability, what has been seen is that the contingency is conceptual or physical instead of legal.19 Of course this report appreciates that there are some ‘properties’ which cannot be categorized as rights as they belong to one person. For instance, it is vague to argue in light of Australian property law that emotions or self-consciousness are properties. Instead of overly relying on Ainswort to support the stance taken by Kevin Gray, commerce test is essential especially in testing what a property is in light of technological advancement. In fact, a number of judges prefer going the commerce test way so as to ensure consistency between commercial meaning and legal meaning of what a property is. A case of the integration of commercial meaning and legal meaning in understanding diversity of property was in Halwood Corporation Ltd v Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties. The argument has been if commerce can treat valuables as well as transferable assets like property then courts should be obligated to do the same. The point at which Kevin Gray believes that a property starts to diminish is that if an item is not commercially valuable then it does not mean the same item should be prevented from being a property under the law. To understand the dimensions of technology with regard to property, James (2005) postulates that the excludability test has to be revisited. First, the privilege (right) to exclude others is the most fundamental of all the property rights.20 Therefore excludability test postulates that an item can be a property if such is physically, conceptually or legally possible to prevent others from using it. The challenge with this test has been its technological contingency. Rather than what courts have held regarding properties and technology, it can be true to believe that properties from which people cannot exclude others can as well be argued not to be anyone’s property instead of making any assumption that such properties cannot be objects of property at all. 5.0. Conclusion This paper is not the first to review controversies that surround the understanding of property law especially in new contexts. It is noted; from cases studies presented that even lawyers struggle to apply property concepts in different dimensions and contexts. As such, the aspect of property vanishing in thin air is strongly supported in the report. It is therefore necessary to have an understanding of the underlying principles in order to apply them to new contexts, perhaps as yet unimagined, as they arise. 6.0. Bibliography James McConvill, ‘Do Shares Constitute Property? Reconsidering a Fundamental, yet Unresolved, Question’ (2005) 79 Australian Law Journal 251. Roger Magnusson, ‘The Use of Human Tissue Samples in Medical Research: Legal Issues for Human Research Ethics Committees’ (2000) 7 Journal of Law and Medicine 390 at 394 Roderick Meagher, Dyson Heydon & Mark Leeming, Meagher, Gummow and Lehane’s Equity: Doctrines and Remedies (2002) at 126. Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Function of Property Law and Effects of Exclusion

Lord Diplocks Key Contributions to Equity Law

Instead, the statute has rendered the distinction between law and equity, a distinction which arose out of 'an accident of history.... The paper "Lord Diplock's Key Contributions to Equity law" states that the debate over the fusion of equitable and common law principles originates from the early development of equity as a separate system from the common law....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Contract Law, Exclusion Clause

From the paper "Contract Law, exclusion Clause" it is clear that generally, in Arthur JS Hall & Co v Simons if there is negligence in providing service to their customers by barristers, no immunity is available to them from exclusion clauses in the contract.... A service provider who deals with his customer cannot enforce his own printed standard terms of conditions thereby cannot either restrict or exclude his accountability for infringement of contract or offer an incomplete service for which he has to demonstrate that exclusion clause is in line with ' test of fairness or reasonableness....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

The Requirements for Protecting the Shape of a Product as a Registered Trademark

1 However, since a number of important cases were decided under the EC Directive on the harmonization of trademarks, the EC Directive and Regulation will be discussed relative to the EU's trademark law and protection of shapes.... This paper demonstrates that developments in EU trademark and design law have reached a point where obtaining protection for shapes as either a registered trademark or design has become particularly difficult.... Critically Analyse the Requirements for Protecting the Shape of a Product as a Registered Trademark and as a Registered Design under EU law By Student Name Course Institute Date Introduction Intellectual property rights protection and enforcement are usually left to national laws of the EU member states....
23 Pages (5750 words) Essay

Parallel Imports Are Good for Welfare, not Bad for Welfare

While some understand it to recognize that inevitably, a mark in one country symbolizes the domestic goodwill of the entity which stands behind the entity in that country, others interpret it merely to mean that domestic law governs the rights of domestic trademark registrants.... The author states that parallel importation raised the possibility that trademarks may not always be able to fulfill their traditionally recognized functions; it has posed a conflict in the two aspects of goodwill, and it raised broader questions of the role of trademark protection in the economy....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

The Functional Consequences of Amblyopia

This essay "The Functional Consequences of Amblyopia" is about correlations that may exist between the multiple visual pathophysiologies.... There are many visual deficits that can occur which is the reason why now amblyopia is considered to be a syndrome of multiple existing conditions.... ... ... ...
35 Pages (8750 words) Essay

The Law of Designs that Has Moved far Beyond Merely Protecting the Aesthetically Pleasing Products

The paper "The law of Designs that Has Moved far Beyond Merely Protecting the Aesthetically Pleasing Products" states that design ownership is characterised by novelty and individual character as well as subjective orientations of the designer that translates to the eye appeal of a product.... This analysis will deal with relevant research studies and legal documentation to explore the reality of the statement that 'The law of designs has moved far beyond merely protecting the aesthetically pleasing products where eye-appeal is material....
53 Pages (13250 words) Research Proposal

The Issue of Gender in Relation to Inclusion and Exclusion

This essay "The Issue of Gender in Relation to Inclusion and exclusion" explores how we are "engendered" (male and female) and what does this mean in relation to inclusion and exclusion in certain aspects of our society.... And whether the technology has changed the dynamics in terms of inclusion and exclusion.... The advent of technology especially in the communication mode spurred further dynamics of Social exclusion/Inclusion....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Taxation Limits on Local Governments, Municipalities and School Districts in the State of Georgia

According to the constitution of the state of Georgia, municipalities are authorized to impose taxes as per the general law or in line with the provisions of the constitution.... The reasons for the existence of such limitations vary, but majorly they are meant to check county government expenditure, Ensure property taxes are maintained at.... The reasons for the existence of such limitations vary, but majorly they are meant to check county government expenditure, Ensure property taxes are maintained at reasonable and reduced rates and improve the accountability of the municipalities and district schools in the collection and the use of public funds (Brazer, 2008)....
20 Pages (5000 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us