StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Problem in Social Security - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
This research paper "The Problem in Social Security" focuses on a compelling argument for the problem in Social Security and how its own system only worsens the dependability of those who rely on disability benefits to eventually impede them from working. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.6% of users find it useful
The Problem in Social Security
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Problem in Social Security"

The article contains a compelling argument for the problem in Social Security and how its own system only worsens the dependability of those who rely on disability benefits to impede them from working. Rich advocates for the utilization of a gradual decrease in the benefit of those who are able to get a job instead of a nine-month cutoff period once the person is able to cross the threshold of $1,000. “That way, they preserved some benefits as they eased back to work, rather than losing them all after just nine months” (par. 8). This argument by the author was based on a study conducted by Social Security Administration’s James Smith, Alice Porter, and Tim Tremblay.

The organization conducted a program in the states of Connecticut, Vermont Utah, and Wisconsin where the benefits of the disabled were gradually reduced over a longer period of time and even up to six years in gainful level. The participants were able to obtain continued disability paychecks beyond the nine months. Another control group, again randomly picked, followed the threshold. The main problem in the case of disability is not the core policies employed by the government but the value system and the overall attitude of the population.

The study and the argument of the author are well and good and rightfully intended but the outlook of the people who are able to take advantage of this program is the main problem why government spending for such purpose has brought a bleak future for this aspect of Social Security. The point of economists and policy analysts in saying that beneficiaries are discouraged from working rings nothing but the truth. Those who are dependent upon the government's hand to survive are dissuaded from taking a full-time job because they will lose their benefit as soon as they hit the thousand-dollar paycheck within nine months.

In the author’s example, he illustrates a simple scenario where a man who works 15 a week for $13 an hour would not want to extend work for another 5 hours as it will make him earn an amount that would make him subject to discontinued disability benefits. This is also a great illustration of the value that is lost in a person who would rather live on a government stipend than work for his own means. To me, the timeframe given by the government of nine months is enough and more than sufficient to ensure that a person is fully on his feet before he is cut off from disability.

The simple fact is we are not talking about a child here who is only beginning to walk for the first time. Most of the people with disability had worked and are capable of working. This is nothing but covetousness disguised in social justice if one is able to work fully but refuses to because he will lose the benefit of government care. It implores upon a man’s sense of decency that he lets others who are in worse need of financial assistance gain from this government's generosity. Even the study is inconclusive since there was a variation in the findings as the desired effects of long-term safety net were only found in Connecticut and Vermont.

The findings in Utah were not mentionable while that in Wisconsin cannot be regarded as significant data (Rich, par. 9). This only shows that it is premature to jump to the conclusion that the solution lies in extending the nine-month grace period is the solution. On the contrary, if a beneficiary is determined to remain in his position, then lengthening the time will not hinder him from doing so through his own will. A stronger and stricter government policy on who gets to be on disability pay and for how long must be implemented as what is happening in most states these days.

Government monitoring is important lest we let those who are able to fend for their selves serve as a burden to those who are earnestly making a living. It has been projected that the disability program is the first benefit program to become insolvent in just a matter of 4-7 years if no step is taken soon. Today, it is estimated that 18% of men aged 25-54 are simply not working. In this regard, $115 billion was spent in 2010 for benefits and another $75 billion for medical treatment. This equates to $1,500 for every household.

“Perhaps the worst thing about the disability program is that, once in it, many people never leave…Relative to a low-paying job, especially if the job exacerbates a chronic injury or chronic pain, the modest monthly disability payment of about $1,100 on average can look appealing” (Leonhardt, par. 6). The debate on welfare and the argument thereof is primarily for the alleviation of poverty. It is intended for both adults and children to guarantee immediate effects. There is a solution offered to include an incentive to work despite providing through welfare and this is the negative income tax (NIT).

Here, there is a minimum income level a family may belong to and a corresponding rate wherein instead of benefits it becomes “taxed away” as income increases (Baumol and Blinder, p.396-397). This seems like a better and more subtle way than that proposed by Rich. The previous perception of the pride of men and the overt reluctance to be on welfare must be enforced. People are getting more dismissive of the fact that they are beneficiaries or that they are bound to be one. What’s bothersome is that this has become matter-of-fact to some people.

This attitude must be suppressed. Attitude is the most important aspect to be established. The amount of $1,500 for each household is no longer applicable to the vicarious benefit that the government seeks to carry out, it is already bordering on lecherous.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Economics Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 1”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1415745-economics
(Economics Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1)
https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1415745-economics.
“Economics Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 1”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/family-consumer-science/1415745-economics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Problem in Social Security

Social Security System

From a lay man's point of view, social security is a simple pension scheme.... But there is more to the social security System than a mere pension arrangement.... The economic gait is that social security is a mechanism whose functioning ensures the provision of revenue for disfavored members of the society such as the old, the handicapped, the ill and the unemployed, so as to enable them meet up with basic necessities.... Like the Balance of Payment (BOP) and the business cycle, the social security System experiences many set backs but there exists a social security problem....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Social Policy and the Social Security System

The paper "Social Policy and the social security System" describes that social security is supposed to be a program to provide financial security, not poverty.... social security was a great moral success of the 20th Century, and we must honor its great purpose in this new century.... And so we must join together to strengthen and save social security.... The threat of bankruptcy that the social security System is facing is a source of much concern throughout the United States and is an issue that the past and current administrations have taken very seriously (The Problems Facing, 1)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Social Security

This essay describes the social security program, that has been the most popular social insurance scheme in the United States of America.... The researcher follows the history of the social security in the United States and analyzes it's strengths and weaknesses.... The essay discusses the social security program, that is most notable in the US.... It is stated that approximately two-thirds of the American population aged 62 and above depend heavily on social security payments for their incomes, with one among five of them depending solely on the payment as a source of livelihood....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Sustainable Development and Food Security

This paper "Sustainable Development and Food security" delves into food security as an important issue among many nations in the world.... This essay will look into food security in third-world nations.... Food security is an important issue among many nations in the world.... The main objective of choosing the subject of food security in third-world nations is because food security is at the heart of many problems....
15 Pages (3750 words) Essay

Social Security Taxation

The paper "social security Taxation" states that some of the recommendations include raising the retirement age, reducing benefits for the high earners, covering social security for all newly hired government employees, recalculating the cost of living assessment levels and using longevity indexes.... One such taxation is that of social security taxation, the proceeds of which are pooled into to provide old-age benefits, pensions, child health, and unemployed....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Social problems in American society

The United States has been faced with security issues, both internal and external.... The government hence invests a lot in security, just to ensure the borders are safe.... The biggest problem currently being faced by the nation is internal security.... Some of the social issues currently affecting the nation are Legality of firearms, Terrorism, and obesity....
4 Pages (1000 words) Research Paper

Development of the Concept of Security

The paper "Development of the Concept of security" explains that security has traditionally been seen in military terms.... The emerging world order compels national leaders to redefine security assumptions and defence strategies.... The challenge of the current period is to expand the domain of alternative security strategies because no single approach will be adequate for all cases.... Arguably, one of the key problems for security policy derives from the recognition that "traditional" strategies, which rely primarily on military force, are counterproductive in many situations....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

The Problem of Food Insecurity and Undernourishment in the World

The author of this paper "the problem of Food Insecurity and Undernourishment in the World" will make an earnest attempt to explore and discuss whether the development of Genetically Modified Organisms solves the problem of food insecurity and undernourishment in the world.... The production of genetically modified organisms fails to present the needed solution to the problem of food scarcity in various parts of the world.... GMO technology has been around for some time now but the problem of food scarcity is still biting hard in many parts of the African continent....
2 Pages (500 words) Annotated Bibliography
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us