StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Case Studies in Ethics - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary

This paper 'Case Studies in Ethics' tells us that this is a delicate situation because the father is upset, and he has a legal background.  This implies that he understands the law well, which leads me to believe he feels that the psychologist was truly negligent in my duties. 
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Case Studies in Ethics
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Case Studies in Ethics"

? Case Studies in Ethics Case Studies in Ethics Chapter 10: The Case of Jamie How would you respond to Jamie’s father’s accusation and refusal to pay your fees? This is a delicate situation because the father is upset, and he has a legal background. This implies that he understands the law well, which leads me to believe he feels that the psychologist was truly negligent in my duties. The psychologist should respectfully respond to him and say that he understands the frustration he feels with the SAT board denial of the request for more time. At the same time, he did the very best he could and is confident that he well documented Jamie’s case and that, unfortunately, the final decision is left to the SAT board. As a professional, he feels that his time should be compensated as agreed upon and he should respectfully ask him to reconsider his decision not to pay. What legal and ethical actions can you take to collect your fees? It is implied from the case study that no written contract was signed stating that there was not a guarantee that the written documentation provided would convince the SAT committee to allow Jamie additional time on the exam. A verbal contract in this case would not be binding because both parties would likely disagree on what was agreed upon. Legally, it does not appear that anything can be done. Can you send the account to a collection agency? Why or why not? FERPA rules guarantee a student’s right to educational privacy. In this case, sending the issue to a collection agency would require a statement of the case, which would most certainly involve the child’s name, or a variation thereof. As such, this would be considered a breach of confidentiality and could actually land the psychologist in trouble. Are the parents or Jamie responsible for the fees? Explain. In this case, the parents would be responsible for the fees. The parents approached the psychologist for the testing; it really had nothing to do with Jamie. To expect Jamie to be responsible for his parents refusal to pay would be ethically wrong. In addition, Jamie is a minor and there was no contract signed where he agreed to pay any fees. For these reasons alone, the parents should be held responsible for 100% of the fees owed to the psychologist. Chapter 11: The Case of Ludwig Do you agree with Ludwig’s clinical decision? Do you agree with his rationale? I do not agree with Ludwig’s clinical decision primarily because it does not appear that he explored all viable options. For one, we do not see where he has discussed the issue with Ella at all. If they have a strong working relationship, as mentioned in the case study, then she would likely be open to hearing his suggestion. At that time, if she completely rejected the idea, then they could formulate other more viable treatment options. One suggestion is that he could advise Ella to go with her family and attend family therapy sessions, while he continued to see her in individual sessions. In this manner, they could continue their strong counseling relationship together. Oddly enough, I do agree with Ludwig’s rationale simply because it makes sense in the context of the decision he made. In his mind, he was watching out for Ella’s best interest, but in doing so, he lost sight of his responsibility to the patient. From your perspective, would it have made a difference if he had consulted with Ella? Would it have made a difference if he had consulted with or obtained supervision from a colleague? In my opinion, it would have made a difference if he had consulted with Ella. It has been established that they have a good counselor-patent relationship already established. As such, it would be likely that Ella would seriously consider his opinion. At the very least, they would have had an open dialogue where Ella could decide to reject or accept Ludwig’s opinion. Had Ludwig consulted with a colleague, he would surely have been counseled that he had an ethical responsibility to refer Ella for family therapy. This would certainly have had an impact on Ludwig’s final decision and would have given him more options to consider. What if Ludwig had decided to see the entire family and attempted to do family therapy for the benefit of his client, even though he was not trained as a family therapist? Ludwig would be shirking his ethical responsibilities as a counselor was he to accept a family for therapy and counseling, and he were not trained to do so. A counselor is to provide the best level of care for their patient. If they cannot do that, primarily because of either a conflict of interest or, in this case, a lack of training, then they are supposed to refer the patient to outside counseling. What if Ludwig had been trained in family systems, but when he suggested family session to Ella, she refused? What would you do if faced with such a dilemma? My first responsibility is to Ella. If she rejected the presented idea of having a family counseling session, I would simply continue to gently encourage her to consider the recommendation, while still seeing her for individual sessions. Perhaps over time she would change her mind. Chapter 12: The Case of Pierre How do you evaluate the ethical appropriateness of Pierre’s approach to discussing confidentiality in his group? I think Pierre did his clients a gross disservice in his oversimplification of matters relating to confidentiality. While confidentiality is guaranteed, with minor exceptions, in an individual session, group sessions are different by their very nature. One cannot hold members of the group responsible legally if they divulge private information. Furthermore, some group members may inadvertently leak privileged information in the course of a normal conversation, without blatantly intending to do so. For Pierre to simply say that ‘anything that happens, stays here’, group members may come with the wrong assumption that their thoughts truly will never be discussed outside of the group setting, which unfortunately simply is not the case. I think Pierre should be much more clear and concise with his description of what confidentiality entails in a group setting. What specific aspects of confidentiality would you most want to inform member of in your group? I would stress members in my group the importance of respecting each other’s privacy. We want everyone in the group to feel free to share openly what is on their mind, but they cannot do that if they fear others in the group will violate the trust that comes with being a part of a group session. I would encourage them to open up to one another and earn each other’s trust, but at the same time to remember what a sacred privilege it is to have someone open up to them in this way. Just as they do not want their own words discussed outside of the group setting, neither do others in the group. What potential problems, if any, do you see in the way Pierre explained confidentiality to group members? There are certainly some potential ethical and licensing problems with the way Pierre explained confidentiality to his group members. Because he simply glossed over the issue, and did so quickly, some in the group may feel he implicitly implied that their confidentiality was guaranteed. If someone in the group then went out and violated that trust and shared private thoughts with others, it could do long lasting harm to the counselor-client relationship. That particular person may never be able to trust a counselor, or such a setting, again. In extreme cases, the person could threaten or do harm to themselves. It is important to carefully consider issues of confidentiality before such matters are shared in an open group counseling session. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 8”, n.d.)
Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 words - 8. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/english/1470973-ethics
(Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 8)
Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 8. https://studentshare.org/english/1470973-ethics.
“Ethics Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 750 Words - 8”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/english/1470973-ethics.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Case Studies in Ethics

Engineering Ethics Case Studies

Firstly, considering one of the codes of ethics indicated, if I am an engineer on a private practice, I may help the other engineer in interpreting the said project but I will not give false views and corrections as a form of injuring the reputation of the more experienced engineer.... However, if both of us or the three of us work for the government, as provided under the codes of ethics, if required, I will help in the interpretation and review of the project but there should be no statements that will damage my colleague's reputation....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Legal & Ethical Case Studies - elementary school

Law and ethics in Elementary Schools Name: Institution: LAW AND ethics IN ELEMENTARY SCHOOLS Teaching profession requires high-level capabilities and techniques in handling issues regarding law and ethics.... In accordance to leadership ethics, the termination was not important (Manos, 2006).... In the case where by the principal and district officers terminate a contract, they should provide a written document detailed with reasons for termination in a period more than six months before the termination date....
3 Pages (750 words) Case Study

Case Studies in Ethnic Conflict

Factors that led to the emergence of the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE) Introduction After independence, it was assumed that Sri Lanka would flourish among its other newly independent Asian neighbours (DeVotta, 2004).... It gained voting rights in 1931, and enjoyed a peaceful transition from colonial rule to a national government in 1948....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Ethics Case Studies

Ethical case studies: Questions and Answers in Research Ethics In this paper, the answers some questions regarding the ethicality of three experiments: the Tearoom Sex Study, the Milgram Experiment, and the Tuskegee Syphilis Study.... This essay deals with the issues that concern ethics.... On a broader level, it is the principle of informed consent that was violated, because the participants were left ignorant of some relevant information regarding their participation in the studies....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethics Case studies

An ethical problem has been generated by this situation since John has no capacity for the job he is seeking and strongly recommending him for it will be against professional ethics.... I would not like to act against professional ethics.... The potential employer depends on me to offer the right information regarding John to ensure that the Lecturer: Presentation: Case An ethical problem has been generated by this situation since John has no capa for the jobhe is seeking and strongly recommending him for it will be against professional ethics....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Ethical Consideration for the Laboratory-Based Studies on Animals

The paper "Ethical Consideration for the Laboratory-Based studies on Animals" highlights that testing on animals is notorious for being unethical, it is in most cases not a matter of choice but a matter of well-being and beneficiary for the human race.... ... ... ... Government, on the other hand, is also very compassionate towards animal rights protection, animal testing is not preferred until and unless it becomes mandatory....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Ethical And Moral Dilemma Case Studies

The paper "Ethical And Moral Dilemma case studies" describes what a panel of persons sit and consider whether a person in offense and serving in prison should be released having served the minimum term prescribed and be monitored under parole explains a 'parole board'.... By letting go of the cocaine case, Linda would be acting against morality and the oath of service she took and the distribution of the drug would cause more harm to the society.... Besides, her failure to attend to back up the burglary case may imply that her fellow officers would be outdone by the criminals and as such the whole force being on the losing side....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Four Cases in Business Ethics

.... ... ... Business EthicsSomething's Rotten in Hondo.... irstly, the headquarters refusal to invest in acquiring new smokestack scrubbers for the company is an ethical issue that is facing the company at the moment.... The fact that the company has problem with the Business EthicsSomething's Rotten in Hondo....
10 Pages (2500 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us