StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Compare and/or contrast the mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Heart and the Fountain - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The execution was done by the ecclesial authorities who sought to censure her work. In analyzing the mysticism in Marguerite’s work and its similarity of difference…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER94.5% of users find it useful
Compare and/or contrast the mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Heart and the Fountain
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Compare and/or contrast the mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Heart and the Fountain"

Comparison of the mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Heart and the Fountain On June 1310, Marguerite Porete was burnt in the fires of Paris because she was believed to be a heretic. The execution was done by the ecclesial authorities who sought to censure her work. In analyzing the mysticism in Marguerite’s work and its similarity of difference from that of Jewish texts, it is central to figure out the meaning of the term mysticism. According to Dan (20), mysticism is a strong religious belief that cannot be expressed in words or periods.

Marguerite was assassinated because she wrote a book pointing out that a soul annihilated in the love of God could grant to nature all it desires. Her words implied that a soul could become one with God, and in the event, ignore the moral law. Marguerite’s beliefs were described as ‘free-spirit’ heresy. From the cataphatic perspective of mysticism, it can be observed that her beliefs were similar to those of medieval Jewish beliefs, which were indicated in their mystical texts. From the early emergence of Jewish mysticism, that is, during the era of the second temple of Judaism, there was a common speculation about man’s ascent into heaven.

Such ascent was also believed to be associated with transformation vision of the glory of god. According to the Jewish texts, the ascetical disciples were required to purify and prepare themselves so as to gain vision of God. In other words, they had to use the language of prophet Ezekiel, whereby one was to have a vision of the glory of God that would then transform them into divine or angelic beings. Both Marguerite’s belief and the Jewish texts indicated that one could attain spiritual perfection while still living on earth.

One crucial difference between the Jewish texts and the form of mysticism presented by Marguerite is that, the Jewish version involved a lengthy process whereby an individual was required to prepare and purify oneself. Additionally, the unity that was proposed in the Jewish texts indicated that the unity was made possible by the glory of God. On the other hand, Marguerite’s view indicated that an individual’s soul was the unifying factor to god. Marguerite views differed with the Jewish texts in that free spirits could attain union with God.

She believed that one could reach a state of free spirits via spiritual abnegation and bodily austerities. She posited that once an individual attained that state, then he or she would be detached from daily concerns. Unlike Marguerite’s work, the Jewish texts were based on ancient scriptures that exhibited cannons of organized religion. The texts were meant to substantiate on the vitality of the Jewish religious observances. The texts had been developed for many centuries, and they included Jewish and kabbalist thoughts that demonstrated esoteric teachings.

Marguerite’s teachings were based on her beliefs on the relationship between a perfect soul and God. The Jewish beliefs views, as presented in their ancient texts, appeared to be experiential, while Marguerite’s views appeared to be speculative in nature. The Jews could trace their beliefs to ancient prophets; while, on the other hand, Marguerite’s work reflected her thoughts that lacked experiential back up. Because of that, her views pointed out that one would gain a peculiar kind of independence after attaining the level of a free spirit, and thus, would not need guidance from sermons or masses.

Works citedDan, Joseph. The Heart and the Fountain: An Anthology of Jewish Mystical Experiences. New York: Oxford University Press, 2002. Print.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Compare and/or contrast the mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Essay”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1611838-compare-andor-contrast-the-mysticism-of-marguerite-porete-and-the-heart-and-the-fountain
(Compare and/Or Contrast the Mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Essay)
https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1611838-compare-andor-contrast-the-mysticism-of-marguerite-porete-and-the-heart-and-the-fountain.
“Compare and/Or Contrast the Mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/religion-and-theology/1611838-compare-andor-contrast-the-mysticism-of-marguerite-porete-and-the-heart-and-the-fountain.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Compare and/or contrast the mysticism of Marguerite Porete and The Heart and the Fountain

The Heptameron by Marguerite de Navarre

The Heptameron, written by the marguerite de Navarre in the sixteenth century, is today considered one of the treasured products of the French Renaissance.... This presents a picture of medicine in sharp contrast to modern times, because of its generalised and careless nature....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Compare and contrast

When jazz became increasingly admired and trendy among people many bands as well as solo singers started… Each singer has a different charisma through which he/she can capture the heart and soul of the listeners and can add energy and attraction in his/her song.... He puts his heart and soul in his songs and he certainly makes them sensational and sentimental....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Compare/contrast Renewable energies vs Nuclear energy

This memo compares and contrasts nuclear energy and renewable sources of energy (wind, solar, hydroelectric, tidal etc.... as the future sources of energy.... The comparison has been made on the basis of the economic feasibility, ease of use, technological advancement and… As an executive of a power sector company, this memo will help you in deciding which technology is more profitable and sustainable in order to give a direction to your future investment. Uranium-235 is the fuel required for nuclear reactors and since uranium Uranium is found in nearly all types of rock and soil bottoms and thus it is readily available for enrichment....
4 Pages (1000 words) Assignment

Compare and contrast

The best way to choose which one is right for you is to compare the similarities and differences between these two vacation destinations. To begin with, compare and Contrast Essay Planning to take a vacation can be a sticky for some people.... The best way to choose which one is right for you is to compare the similarities and differences between these two vacation destinations....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Mysticism in Hinduism

This will bring joy to our heart and self-realization to our life.... There are many people who unsuccessfully try to understand the supreme Hindu mysticism.... mysticism in Hinduism We may study mysticism if we want.... There are many people who unsuccessfully try to understand the supreme Hindu mysticism.... It is important to understand that Hindu mysticism is not autohypnosis and not self-delusion but the unity with infinity, eternity and immorality....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

To Marguerite Continued

Two images in Conrad's “heart of Darkness” that could portray a clash between the two cultures of Africa and Europe are “an impenetrable forest” and “…till you thought yourself bewitched and cut off forever from everything you had known once – somehow – far away in another existence perhaps.... The author of the current work "To marguerite Continued" explains that the meaning of the poem is established by contrasting images of connection and separation....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Sri Ramakrishna and Mysticism

This report "Sri Ramakrishna and mysticism" discusses the life and teachings of Ramakrishna.... The diversity in the interpretations is not the surprising one as it refers to someone's latent mysticism practices.... ( McDaniel, 95)Originated from the Greek language, the term mysticism refers to the phenomena of concealing.... A secret Religious ritual is also one form of mysticism as defined by the Hellenistic world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Report

Important Details of Life and Work of Marguerite Duras

The paper focuses on marguerite who is considered as an important writer and a film director because her novels brought out her literature manner that had a beautiful prose style.... marguerite Duras grew up in very poor family background.... The extreme poverty situation that the family went through is later reflected in marguerite's life and work.... In her novel, marguerite has reported that she was beaten up by her mother and older brother during the time that she started the affair with the Chinese merchant....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us