StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Empirically Supported Treatment - Case Study Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Empirically Supported Treatment" discusses that the therapist also interprets the child’s attitude and behavior towards him, the child’s family and the environment through their interactions. The child is made to think into the past and associate his feelings with past experiences…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92% of users find it useful
The Empirically Supported Treatment
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Empirically Supported Treatment"

1 The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy: Science and Policy Introduction The history of 'EST', i.e. the Empirically Supported Treatment movement goes back to 1995. Initially, the idea of creating a list of empirically supported treatments came about when it was observed that practice guidelines were giving priority to psychopharmacology over psychotherapy. Psychopharmacology was presumed to be more scientifically and research based as compared to psychotherapy. It was believed that, if there was a list of therapies which used controlled research methods and claimed success in treating disorders, then psychotherapy could also claim to be research and true science based. This in turn would help promote psychotherapy. In 1995, it was determined that professionals should be trained exclusively in the use of Empirically Supported or Validated Therapies. This move was given a push when the American Psychologists Association (APA) published the first of its task force reports. Since then Empirically Validated Therapy (EVT), Empirically Supported Therapy (EST), and Evidence Based Practice (EBP), refers to therapeutic treatments which are deemed empirically sound and valid, by a particular research methodology. Thus these therapies or treatments can be officially used in the psychotherapy. This however implied that those therapies which do not make the list are not empirically valid and these alternative methods of treatment are therefore considered irrelevant. This stirred up a hornet's nest in the world of psychotherapy and was the beginning of a controversy which persists even today. The Empirically Validated Treatment movement brought about a split between psychotherapists, i.e. those who saw themselves as scientists and those who saw themselves as practitioners. 2 Many Psychotherapists believed and in fact, still believe that although this therapy is a science, it deals with human emotions which vary a great deal from person to person and hence a humanistic psychodynamic approach has to be used which is tailored to individual clients. If this is the case then most of their techniques would not validated by the strict research methodology put forward for Empirical validation. Today, the controversy continues as the psychotherapists challenge the traditional methods of research and expose unsubstantiated assumptions on which this research is based and therapies accepted as Empirically Validated/Supported Therapies. Arguments for the Empirically Validated/ Supported Treatment It is important to know why and how the Empirically Validated/Supported Treatment came into being. The American Psychiatrists Association developed the Empirically Validated Treatment (EVT). These were mostly medications and validation methods favoring biological treatment approaches. This is when the American Psychologists Association decided to develop their own EVT. The psychologists did not like the idea of research proving therapy or the claim that the success of a therapy could be proven. Since validated could mean proven, they changed the terminology to EST, i.e. Empirically Supported Treatment. The arguments for having EST in psychotherapy are extremely valid and relevant. 3 1. Psychotherapy is a Science: Psychotherapists have always been considered scientists and psychotherapy a science. However science demands empirical validation of theory. Thus it is maintained that only effective psychotherapy which is supported by empirical proof should be considered for treatment. It is inconceivable that physicians would conduct experimental treatments without the consent of patients or that FDA would approve medicines without proof of their efficacy and knowledge of side-effects. To the scientific committee it is therefore shocking that there is no way of determining what is and what is not effective psychotherapy. Hence for psychotherapy to remain in the realms of science it is necessary that ESTs be used in the clinics. 2. Protection of Patients: In the 1970's and 80's there were a multitude of psychotherapy approaches and many more were being developed. Interest in Psychotherapy was on the rise and in this environment it flourished unchecked. These therapies were being applied without examining the dangers or the validity of their theories. An example of this was the therapy for satanic ritual abuse. There is also a possibility that these therapies could prove dangerous for the patient, who has had no way of determining what is and is not effective psychotherapy. Thus formulation of ESTs leads to effective therapies and protects the patient as well as the credibility of Psychotherapy. 4 3. Protection of Psychotherapists: In a society in which litigations are on the increase and the risks of psychotherapists being sued are high, it is imperative to have and follow a standard like ESTs for their own safety. 4. Psychotherapy and Medical Science: A standard like EST helps the science of psychology to hold its own and be parallel to medical sciences, such that it remains viable in an atmosphere where cheaper and less time consuming medical sciences like psychopharmacology hold sway. Arguments against the Empirically Validated/ Supported Treatment It is necessary to understand what characterizes EST research to be able to understand the arguments of psychotherapists against it. The most important criteria for EST laid out by Division 12 task force is as follows: (a) a specified focus of treatment that can be reliably and validly assessed; (b) a specified treatment population; (c) a treatment well-described, typically by a treatment manual; and (d) the use of random assignment to treatment or comparison conditions for group research or of solid single-case experimental designs for small sample research. It is believed by many psychotherapists that Empiricism is not the only valid, primary or most valuable approach to assessing therapy. They believe that empiricism often does not relate to the real world and that the insistence for empirical research, for all its talk about science, is a dogmatic position of faith that downplays and ignores the possibility of 5 alternative methods. They believe that legitimate alternative techniques exist, and that they are probably more promising than a strictly empiricist methodology. Some of the arguments against EST are 1. Limitation of measures: too much confidence is ascribed to clinical measures. Measures are limited and give one view of a construct (such as depression) from within a theoretical framework. 2. Limitation of research methodology: The empirical methodology gives preference to quantitative research over qualitative approaches. 3. Myopic views of mental health: many measures are theory dependent and overly simplistic. 4. Limitations of creativity and innovation: Using treatment which is only empirically validated would limit creativity and slow down the process of innovation. 5. Assumptions of appropriate ends: Measures should be consistent with the theories they are measuring. Different results might be obtained if different measures are used than the ones that should be for measuring different therapies. The factor is not taken into consideration in most empirical research. 6 The narrowing of therapy: Using measures of symptoms to assess therapy tends to make many assumptions about the purpose of that therapy. Despite the emergence of new 6 measures of well-being and psychological health, our understanding of how therapy impacts the individual on the whole is limited. Applications of Both Positions The case study, that is going to be looked into, is that of an eight year old male child who has a phobia of dogs. The child has a history of breaking into a sweat at the sight of a dog, even at a distance. He complains of palpitations, sweating and dizziness when a dog comes close to him. He starts screaming and collapses when the dog is next to him. The parents brought the child in with a hope to get him over his phobia. He isn't comfortable with most animals but panic assails him when he is in proximity to a dog. Treatment plan of those who support EST: The treatment thought to be most effective to treat this type of phobia in a child is the Cognitive- Behavior Therapy. This therapy is known to bring about a significant improvement in cases dealing with phobias and anxiety. It is based on Desensitization and Confrontation, relaxation techniques and reward systems. The child was initially made to see a dog's picture in a book and assess his feelings and rationalize them with the help of a therapist. The next step was to observe a dog in a pet shop from a distance. All the time the therapist tried reasoning with the child, restructuring his thoughts and actions into a more assertive and adaptive framework. As the child 7 overcame his anxiety, he was made to observe another child petting the dog. The next step was to enter the shop and be close to a small puppy and then petting it while somebody helped him. At each step as the boy overcame his phobia he was rewarded. Later he was made to pet a dog of a larger size on a leash and then one without a leash. At the end of the therapy, the child had overcome most of his phobia and could handle being around dogs. Treatment plan of those who did not support EST: Psychodynamic therapy was used to treat the boy who suffered from a phobia of dogs. This therapy, which is very like psychoanalysis but less intense, is not supported by the EST. Here the therapist helps make a connection between mind and body. The child is not made to directly confront his phobia. Instead through play therapy, the child confronts his fears. The therapist labels these feelings to help the child put them into perspective. The therapist also interprets the child's attitude and behavior towards him, the child's family and environment through their interactions. The child is made to think into the past and associate his feelings with past experiences. Individuals in the child's environment are asked to participate to enable them to help the child make the required changes in his surroundings. Confronting his problems helps him to deal with his phobia for dogs. References 1. The Effectiveness Of Psychotherapy: Science and Policy by D. H. Barlow. Published in Vol. 3 of the 1996 journal, Clinical Psychology: Science and Practice, on pages 236-240. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words, n.d.)
The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1504439-the-effectiveness-of-psychotherapy
(The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1504439-the-effectiveness-of-psychotherapy.
“The Effectiveness of Psychotherapy Case Study Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”. https://studentshare.org/psychology/1504439-the-effectiveness-of-psychotherapy.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Empirically Supported Treatment

Current Treatments for Children with Autism

empirically supported Comprehensive Treatments for Young Children With Autism”.... The paper “Current Treatments for Children with Autism” aims at reflecting over those current treatment methods that would help a child with autism to lead a normal life.... Naturally, children with autism become subjects of harsh treatment from people around them and ultimately the entire situation is worsened for victims of this disease....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Evidence-Based Practice and Empirically Supported Treatment in Future Practice

Likewise there is empirically supported treatment which is also based on a proven treatment procedure.... Both evidence based Running Head: EVIDENCE BASED PRACTICE AND empirically supported treatment Evidence based practice and empirically supported treatment in future practice NameInstitutionEvidence based practice and empirically supported treatment in future practice Evidence based practice in psychology is the medical process that entails the intentional and explicit use of currently available secondary sources of data and medical research journals as evidence towards a conclusive decision making....
2 Pages (500 words) Term Paper

How to Reform Psychology

he clinicians also believe in clinical experience as a main focus in decision-making regarding the treatment.... Scientific-based medicine, on the other hand, is a method of treatment that relies on valid results.... However, there are some chances for such treatment method not to be effective.... This practice is in relation to the fact that clinicians often do not want to see their patients suffering for long in the name of proving the efficacy of the new treatment method....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

The Role of Spirituality in the Treatment of Depression

This review "The Role of Spirituality in the treatment of Depression" discusses empirical research and on fundamental principles of what a clinician should be, there is a convincing case to be made on behalf of encouraging more psychiatrists to take into account religious and spiritual values.... However, as psychiatry begins to shift away from these older perspectives, it will nevertheless begin to find a practical and theoretical use for spirituality and religiosity in the treatment of moderate to severe cases of mental illness....
6 Pages (1500 words) Literature review

Evidenced-Based Practice and Empirically Supported Treatment

The "Evidenced-Based Practice and empirically supported treatment" paper states that the implementation of EBP and empirical supported treatment is significantly important and has helped clinicians improve the quality of health care they provide to their patients.... nbsp; empirically supported treatment is the administration of medical care based on experiments and observations.... (Hunsley, 2007)The importance of evidence-based practice and empirically supported systems can therefore not be underestimated since it is the driving force to this transformation....
6 Pages (1500 words) Coursework

Evidence-Based Practice in Nursing

… Evidence Based Nursing (EBN)Table of ContentIntroductionPolicy context of research and EBPAppraisal of research paradigms Evaluation of aspects of the research process Ethical frameworksData collectionAnalysis Evidence Based Nursing (EBN)Table of ContentIntroductionPolicy context of research and EBPAppraisal of research paradigms Evaluation of aspects of the research process Ethical frameworksData collectionAnalysis ConclusionBibliography/ReferencesI....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Child Security Work

… Evidence Based Practice It is obvious that child security work has, in current times, become more and more multifaceted.... It is gradually more politicised and subject to media attention.... The numbers of child protection workers have enlarged but the Evidence Based Practice It is obvious that child security work has, in current times, become more and more multifaceted....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Comparative Analysis of Treatment Options for Schizophrenia

The paper "Comparative Analysis of treatment Options for Schizophrenia" state that schizophrenia is tremendously complex in its aetiology and presentation, with much of its aspects such as development, origin, pathology, and treatment is widely unknown.... This takes several stages: engagement, assessment, tracing of beliefs, elicit metacognitions, symptom normalization and establishment of alternative mechanisms, hallucinations reattribution and treatment of negative symptoms (Marcinko & Read, 2004)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us