StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Debate Topic - Research Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
Name Instructor Class 9 April 2011 Generic Drugs and Patent-less Drugs The Trade-related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement of the World Trade Organization creates minimum standards for intellectual property rights (Williams 1). TRIPS demands developing countries to commence property rights legislation that are the same with the developed countries (Williams 1)…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.4% of users find it useful
Debate Topic
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Debate Topic"

9 April Generic Drugs and Patent-less Drugs The Trade-related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement of the WorldTrade Organization creates minimum standards for intellectual property rights (Williams 1). TRIPS demands developing countries to commence property rights legislation that are the same with the developed countries (Williams 1). TRIPS assert that developing countries must adjust existing national legislation to ramp up property rights and expand coverage to all areas including medicines (Williams 1).

Furthermore, property rights protection must have, at a minimum, a twenty-year protection (Williams 1). Many developing countries had not covered medicines and pharmaceutical products, because of its disadvantages to generic drug research and production. Multinational Corporations (MNCs) should manufacture cheap generic life saving drugs for poor countries or give up their patents to others who want to make generic drugs, because it will save millions of lives, allow development of generic and patent-less drugs, and breed innovation.

The poor have the right to free or cheaper generic drugs and MNCs should not hinder them from getting the pharmaceutical products they need. The pros of cheap generic life saving drugs or giving up drug patents are: 1) Millions of lives are saved, 2) Other drug companies can develop cheaper drugs or patent-less drugs that will benefit the public, and 3) Large companies will benefit from innovation, because they will no longer have to depend on their blockbuster products for revenues, and instead, they will be pushed to develop generic life saving drugs.

Boseley reports about Glaxo which stopped Africans from buying a cheaper version of its AIDS Drugs. It is an inhumane act, because South Africa only wants to do something right- to help its own people, which large drug MNCs are not looking after. AIDS drugs, for instance, are already being widely developed as generic drugs in India and Brazil, according to Shah and the Economist. They are finding ways to help respond to the overwhelming demand for generic or patent-less drugs. If the MNCs do not want to provide generic versions of their drugs, then the following solutions are forwarded. 1. To lower the price of the product, so the minorities can also afford it.

They should lower their products competitively compared to generic drugs (The Economist). The poor can still be their market through selling cheaper medicine to their government, who in turn can provide the medicine for free or for lower prices. 2. Government should help with tax incentive on the product. They should give MNCs tax incentives, so that they can greatly lower the prices of their products and make them more affordable for the poor. 3. To lower the patent life to 5-6 years, so another company can sell it afterwards.

The government should not follow TRIPs policies on patenting and follow the least years of patenting instead. 4. Government should provide tax incentives for smaller biomedical companies in emerging economies, so that they can invent affordable treatments for a variety of neglected diseases which hardly ever make headlines, but involve almost a billion people in some way (Shah). These tax incentives should promote the development of generic drugs. 5. Governments should enact “Bolar provisions”, which permit generic firms to undertake research and development work on drugs still under patent (The Economist).

This way, once the patent has lapsed; other companies can release their generic drugs faster for the public. 6. MNCs should allow voluntary licensing or compulsory licensing for life-saving products, not lifestyle products. In a compulsory license, a government compels the holder of a patent, copyright, or other exclusive right to grant use to the state or others. Frequently, the holder does receive some royalties, by law or determined through arbitration. Voluntary licensing involves the patent holder providing license to other parties,” on an exclusive or nonexclusive basis, the right to manufacture, import, and/or distribute a pharmaceutical product” (World Health Organization).

MNCs should know that it is not ethical to charge exorbitant prices on life-saving drugs. They should manufacture cheap generic life saving drugs for poor countries or give up their patents to others who want to make generic drugs, because it will save millions of lives, permit the development of generic and patent-less drugs, and raise innovation. MNCs can still make money through different licensing agreements, but not as high as they want to. They have to consider the morality of their pricing and patenting policies, when millions of lives are at stake.

Outline of the paper 1. The Trade-related Intellectual Property Rights (TRIPS) agreement of the World Trade Organization creates minimum standards for intellectual property rights. 1.1 TRIPS assert that developing countries must adjust existing national legislation to ramp up property rights and expand coverage to all areas including medicines (Williams 1). Furthermore, property rights protection must have, at a minimum, a twenty-year protection (Williams 1). 1.2 Many developing countries had not covered medicines and pharmaceutical products, because of its disadvantages to generic drug research and production. 1.3 Multinational Corporations (MNCs) should manufacture cheap generic life saving drugs for poor countries or give up their patents to others who want to make generic drugs, because it will save millions of lives, allow development of generic and patent-less drugs, and breed innovation. 2. The poor have the right to free or cheaper generic drugs and MNCs should not hinder them from getting the pharmaceutical products they need. 2.1 Millions of lives are saved. 2.2 Other drug companies can develop cheaper drugs or patent-less drugs that will benefit the public. 2.3 Large companies will benefit from innovation, because they will no longer have to depend on their blockbuster products for revenues, and instead, they will be pushed to develop generic life saving drugs. 3. If the MNCs do not want to provide generic versions of their drugs, then the following solutions are forwarded. 3.1 To lower the price of the product, so the minorities can also afford it. 3.2 Government should help with tax incentive on the product. 3.3 To lower the patent life to 5-6 years, so another company can sell it afterwards. 3.4 Government should provide tax incentives for smaller biomedical companies in emerging economies, so that they can invent affordable treatments for a variety of neglected diseases which hardly ever make headlines, but involve almost a billion people in some way (Shah). 3.5 Governments should enact “Bolar provisions”, which permit generic firms to undertake research and development work on drugs still under patent (The Economist). 3.6 MNCs should allow voluntary licensing or compulsory licensing for life-saving products, not lifestyle products. 4. MNCs should know that it is not ethical to charge exorbitant prices on life-saving drugs. 4.1 They should manufacture cheap generic life saving drugs for poor countries or give up their patents to others who want to make generic drugs, because it will save millions of lives, permit the development of generic and patent-less drugs, and raise innovation. 4.2 MNCs can still make money through different licensing agreements, but not as high as they want to. 4.3 They have to consider the morality of their pricing and patenting policies, when millions of lives are at stake.

Works Cited Boseley, Sarah. Glaxo Stops Africans Buying Cheap AIDS Drugs. Guardian.co.uk, 2 Dec. 2000. Web. 8 April 2011 . Shah, Anup. Pharmaceutical Corporations and Medical Research. Global Issues, 2010. Web. 8 April 2011 < http://www.globalissues.org/article/52/pharmaceutical-corporations-and-medical-research>. The Economist. Screwing the Brand Names. The Economist, 16 Sept. 2004. Web. 8 April 2011 . Williams, Mariama. The TRIPS and Public Health Debate: An Overview. 2001. Web. 8 April 2011 .

World Health Organization. Cost-Containment Mechanisms for Essential Medicines, Including Antiretrovirals, in China - Health Economics and Drugs Series No. 013. 2003. 8 April 2011 .

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Debate Topic Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1415667-debate-topic
(Debate Topic Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words)
https://studentshare.org/other/1415667-debate-topic.
“Debate Topic Research Paper Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 500 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1415667-debate-topic.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Debate Topic

Counter argument about the Drone Warfare

This has made the use of drones a major Debate Topic among individuals and states.... Name Instructor Class Drone Warfare Drone warfare has become a common phenomenon with major world powers such as the United States, Russia and China embracing its use in war and reconnaissance missions....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Debate topic Abortion Should Be Illegal in Canada

Abortion is a subject of hot debate the world over.... 194286 28 November 2007 Abortion Should Be Illegal in Canada Abortion is a of hot debate the world over.... In Canada, the issue is being debated solely for the purpose of encouraging couples to have babies than the opposite of what is being seen mostly in third world countries where there are dismal factors like poverty to discourage unwanted pregnancies....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Terrorism and criminology

Often seen as an amoral and disproportionately violent act in response to certain situations, terrorism the favorite Debate Topic of social scientists and political analysts the world over.... Often seen as an amoraland disproportionately violent act in response to certain situations, terrorism the favorite Debate Topic of social scientists and political analysts the world over....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Tax Deductibility of a Group Health Insurance

Kathleen Adams, PhD Objective: To propose the debate that tax deductibility of employees is detrimental in the delivery of health benefits since it promotes overspending and favors high-income earners.... Broader level of health insurance creates social value leading to formation and maintenance of risk pool to the employed (Pauly,… In addition, this tax regime disrupts efficiency of market labor, reduces efficiency of health insurance, and provision of health care services. Conclusion: changing the tax exclusion is critical in increasing retention although this also reduces job mobility and Tax Deductibility of Employer-Sponsored Health Insurance Tax deductibility of employer-sponsored (group) health insurance Authors: Patricia Ketsche, PhD, William Custer, PhD, and E....
1 Pages (250 words) Article

Caring for the Earth and Its Inhabitants

This essay, Caring for the Earth and Its Inhabitants, declares that the phenomenon of global warming is a hot Debate Topic today.... nbsp; The phenomenon of global warming is a hot Debate Topic today.... Nevertheless, there exist substantial and compelling evidence that shows that the mean temperature of the earth has risen considerably over a few decades....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Assessing Infrastructure Failure

This essay discusses that infrastructure plays an important function in the communities through sustains and acts in response to natural calamities to lessen their brunt, such as buildings for safe haven and bridges for flight.... hellip; In today's global warming, extreme weather conditions pose a high risk of structural failure of infrastructure....
1 Pages (250 words) Essay

Conceptions of Bureaucracy, Bureaucratic Way of Operations

This essay describes the government runs on the bureaucratic system in which elected officials make the most important decisions as the ones specialized in dealing with the tasks presented, who will implement the policies.... In relation, bureaucracy has its advantages and dis-advantages.... hellip; About bureaucracy, usually, the people in leadership are not the ones chosen or elected by the public....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Global Warming and the Climate Change

Global warming constitutes a Debate Topic that has been pursued for three centuries now.... Scientists have differed in this debate, arguing for and against the link between carbon dioxide and global warming.... The paper “Global Warming and the Climate Change” seeks to evaluate the global warming phenomenon, which is not likely to stop if necessary action, measures, and policies are not formulated and implemented....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us