StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Nelson Goodmanss New Riddle Of Induction - Term Paper Example

Cite this document
Summary
The traditional problem of induction was popularized by David Hume and it reamined quite traditional until Nelson Goodman proposed a new problem which he called “the new riddle of induction” as expressed in the third chapter of Fact, Fiction and Forecast…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91.8% of users find it useful
Nelson Goodmanss New Riddle Of Induction
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Nelson Goodmanss New Riddle Of Induction"

NELSON GOODMANS’S NEW RIDDLE OF INDUCTION The traditional problem of induction was popularized by David Hume and it reamined quite traditional untilNelson Goodman proposed a new problem which he called “the new riddle of induction” as expressed in the third chapter of Fact, Fiction and Forecast. The New Problem By the new riddle of induction Goodman put forward a claim that not all generalizations are confirmed by their instances. In other words “confirmation of a hypothesis by an instance depends rather heavily upon the features of the hypothesis other than its syntatical form” (72).

He distinguished the lawlike (that a given piece of copper conducts electricity increases the credibility of the statement asserting that other pieces of copper conducts electricity, and thus confirms the hypothesis that all copper conducts electricity) and accidental (that a given man now in this room is a third son does not increase the credibility of the statement asserting that other men now in this room are third sons and so does not confirm the hypothesis that all men now in this room are third sons) statements.

Yet, both are cases in which the hypothesis is a generalization of the evident statement. Thus, Goodman argued: “only a statement that is lawlike – regardless of its truth or falsity or its scientific importance – is capable of recieviing confirmation from an instance of it; accidental statements are not” (73). As such, there is need for a way of plainly distinguishing the lawlike from the accidental statements. However, the problem of induction goes beyond merely trying to exclude a few cases that are admitted by our definition of confirmation.

Hence, Goodman proposed a new predicate, “grue.” The predicate “grue” applies to things examined before time t just in case they are green but to other things just in case they are blue. Supposing that all emeralds examined before a certain time t are green, at t, our observation supports the hypothesis that all emeralds are green since our evidence statements assert that emeralds a, b, c and so on are green. But with the new predicate “grue” at t we have for each evidence asserting that a given emerald is green, an equally coressponding evidence asserting that it is grue.

Thus, the two predications are confirmed by evidence statements describing the same observations. This example put forward by Goodman futher stresses his claim that the difficulty in determining what constitutes lawlike hypotheses is far more complex than previously thought so that once again the initial dilema remains: “anything can confirm anything.” Goodman and Hume Although the initial problem of induction as expoused by Hume, by which anything can follow upon anything else, was thought by Goodman as dissolved (59).

The more pertinent problem is that any statement could confirm any other. Even upon futher modification of the definition of confirmation, the problem remains unresolved. Thus, Goodman held that Hume’s real problem was not in his descriptive approach but in the lack of precision in his description; for though some regularities establish habits, others do not. Conclusion On a conclusive note, the aftermath of Goodman’s new riddle were attempts to resolve the new problem which he proposed. In my opinion, Goodman’s problem may well be a psuedo-problem: is Goodman’s grue actually projectible?

Surely in concrete epistemic situation, the predicate “grue” is not actually projectible, but in certain counterfactual epistemic situations, it may be. If Goodman's riddle is indeed projecting a new property for emeralds, for instance, which has not been experinced in the past, then it is not really a problem of induction since induction is a kind of hypothesizing about a whole based on past observations of the part of a class. Thus, although the conclusion is supported by the premises, it does not follow necessarily from them.

Also, Goodman’s new predicate could not legitimately fit into a scientific discourse because it is less simple than its corresponding predicate “green” since it is defined in terms of two other predicates. BIBLIOGRAPHY Goodman, Nelson. Fact, Fiction and Forecast. Cambridge: Harvard University Press, 1955.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Nelson Goodmanss New Riddle Of Induction Term Paper”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/other/1412891-nelson-goodmanss-new-riddle-of-induction
(Nelson Goodmanss New Riddle Of Induction Term Paper)
https://studentshare.org/other/1412891-nelson-goodmanss-new-riddle-of-induction.
“Nelson Goodmanss New Riddle Of Induction Term Paper”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/other/1412891-nelson-goodmanss-new-riddle-of-induction.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Nelson Goodmanss New Riddle Of Induction

The Philosophy of Science and The Problem of Confirming Scientific Hypotheses

In the third section, I shall focus on Nelson Goodman's (1983) “new riddle of induction.... Herein, I shall discuss David Hume's (1978) problem of induction, a theory closely related to the problem of confirming scientific hypotheses.... Confirmation and Induction “The confirmation of theories is closely connected to another classic issue in philosophy: the problem of induction” (Godfrey-Smith, 2003, p.... Now the problem of induction is magnified in Hume's (1978) “problem of induction....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Problem of Induction

The problem of induction relates to the philosophical inquiry into the possibility of inductive reasoning leading to understanding of classical philosophical logic.... hellip; The Problem of induction Induction is basically a process of reasoning in which an individual makes inferences from a more specific to the general.... This paper explores the challenge that the problem of induction raises for the status of scientific knowledge and possible solution to the challenge....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Placebo Effects in the Meta-Analyses of Hrobjartsson and Gotzsche

The topic of placebo effects is a highly contentious issue; even agreement on a standard definition remains elusive.... The following dissertation aims to review current debates into placebo effects, especially focusing on the discourse initiated by the meta-analyses of Hrobjartsson and Gotzsche in 2001 and 2004....
32 Pages (8000 words) Essay

Role of Exercise in Preventing and Treating Osteoporosis

It greatly affects elderly females.... It is observed that in case of osteoporosis, reduction occurs only in bone mass and not in bone mineralization.... Any… urbance in regular structural design of bone or any loss of trabecular prerequisites or a decline in skeletal connections or cortical covering is considered as osteoporosis....
10 Pages (2500 words) Literature review

Protein Intake and Bone Loss and Bone Fractures

The author of the "Protein Intake and Bone Loss" paper argues that there is a lack of adequate research on the effect of protein on bone health and more well-controlled studies are, thus, required before a definite answer can be reached.... More such research could help in the prevention of fractures....
6 Pages (1500 words) Term Paper

The Philosophy of Science

In the third section, I shall focus on Nelson Goodman's (1983) “new riddle of induction.... hellip; Science is limited by its use of induction as a means of confirmation.... Herein, I shall discuss David Hume's (1978) problem of induction, a theory closely related to the problem of confirming scientific hypotheses.... “The confirmation of theories is closely connected to another classic issue in philosophy: the problem of induction” (Godfrey-Smith, 2003, p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

Why is Hepatitis E of Increasing Importance for Developing as well as Developed Countries

This work "Why is Hepatitis E of Increasing Importance for Developing as well as Developed Countries" focuses on Hepatitis E as a liver disease that is caused by the Hepatitis E Virus.... The author outlines why the case for hepatitis E is significant, its role in developed countries.... nbsp;… HEV has one serotype but four genotypes....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

New Riddle of Induction and Nelson Goodman's Approach to the Problem of Induction

… The paper “new riddle of induction and Nelson Goodman's Approach to the Problem of Induction” is a cogent variant of essay on philosophy....   The paper “new riddle of induction and Nelson Goodman's Approach to the Problem of Induction” is a cogent variant of essay on philosophy.... As Goodman sets out to describe the new riddle of induction he defines the set of laws that make up inductive assumptions that are valid and those that are not valid....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us