StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Patient Diagnosed With Cancer - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
An essay "Patient Diagnosed With Cancer" addresses a two-fold objective to wit:  to identify the principles of professional nursing practice and to outline the ethical and legal frameworks for professional practice and incorporate evidenced-based practice in relation to quality patient care…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Patient Diagnosed With Cancer
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Patient Diagnosed With Cancer"

Patient Diagnosed With Cancer Abstract The essay aims to address a two-fold objective to wit: (1) to identify the principles of professional nursing practice; and (2) to outline the ethical and legal frameworks for professional practice and incorporate evidenced-base practice in relation to quality patient care. Case Study Introduction/ State the Problem This paper will study the case of Tabitha and determine the rights of the client based on Kerridge, Lowe and McPhee (2005) Model for Ethical Decision Making. In addition, this case study will discuss the ethics and legality of minor patients in terms of decision to receive or refuse treatment, as well as the capacity of the parents to give consent. Tabitha is 1-year-old patient who was diagnosed with cancer two years ago and has received two courses of chemotherapy. She understands and respects every decision with regards to treatment and is due to have another round of chemotherapy. The treatment can make a 30% chance of survival or approximately two years. Without this, Tabitha will die within three months. Tabitha has a good relationship with clinical team. She also has a supportive family and friends all throughout the treatment. She attends the local school when she is not sick and lives with her brothers and parents. The ethical dilemma started when Tabitha refused consent chemotherapy because of being fed up in the hospital to receive unpleasant treatments. According to the ANMC National Competency Standards for the Registered Nurse Section 2.3 (2008), a registered nurse practices in way that acknowledge the dignity, culture, values, beliefs and rights of individual groups, including the consideration of individual/group preferences when providing care (p. 3). Respecting Tabitha’s refusal to treatment is in line with the practice of professional and ethical nursing framework; however, doing so might sacrifice the safety of Tabitha and death within three months. The legal issue in this case study centered on Tabitha’s right to make decision. Although she is mature enough to understand the treatment and her parents are supportive of the decision to refuse chemotherapy, she is still a 16-year-old patient. According to New South Wales Department of Health (2005), children and young people under the age of 18 should not solely make treatment limitations decisions especially on end-of-life care, even if decision-making capacity is unquestionable (p. 12). State the Facts Cancer is a disease that affects all age groups and has caused high mortality rates not only among Australia but in U.S. population. Cancer refers to a group of diseases that has multisystem effects and there are many types of it. It was not stated in the case study what type of cancer Tabitha has but this paper will discuss cancer in general. Cancer involves altered cell differentiation and growth that results in a process called neoplasia or new growth (Porth, 2010, 131). Cell division in cancer is both abnormal and uncontrolled most especially if people are at risk for developing cancer. Heredity, environment, and lifestyle play a vital role in the development of cancer. The pathophysiology of cancer is integrated in the process called carcinogenesis or oncogenesis. Here, cellular transformation underwent four stages, namely: initiation, promotion, progression, and metastasis (Daniels & Nicoll, 2012, 317). In the initiation, a carcinogen invades, damages, and changes the DNA of the cell. Promotion immediately follows where the initiated cell is repeatedly exposed to a promoter that causes cellular proliferation and the carcinogen becomes a promoter and a malignant tumor. The malignant cell increases in size and malignancy, becomes more anaplastic, and less differentiated – signals of morphological change during the progression stage. It is also in this stage when the primary malignant tumor established its own blood supply and formed new blood vessels through the process known as angiogenesis (Daniels & Nicoll, 2012, 317). The fourth stage of cancer development is the metastasis – the spread of malignant tumor to other location through direct invasion to nearby tissues or spreading to distant sites by venous circulation. Clinical manifestations of cancer depend upon the primary site of tumor or involvement. However, most common clinical manifestations include: ulceration, necrosis and bleeding among compressed and eroded blood vessels, effusions in pleural, pericardial and peritoneal spaces, anemia, anorexia and cachexia, fatigue and sleep disorders, and paraneoplastic syndromes (Porth, 2010, 146). The triad treatment for cancer includes surgery, pharmacotherapy with chemotherapy, and radiation. Other complementary and alternative therapies are also used to ease the symptoms, pain, or due to cultural beliefs; among of which include acupuncture, chelation therapy, energy healing, guided imagery, natural products, yoga, and others (Daniels & Nicoll, 2012, 300). Cancer prognosis has been better since the last decades and treatments can now cause permanent destruction of cancer cells, remission of the disease, and improvement of the quality of life. Four Ethical Principles Autonomy refers to the ethical principle that focuses on the right of the patient to make decisions on any interventions that may affect the quality of life (Finkelman & Kenner, 2010, 197). As a patient, Tabitha has the right to have autonomy towards her treatment; however, being a 16-year-old patient complicates the situation whether Tabitha’s decision to refuse chemotherapy would be upheld in respect of patient’s autonomy or may be violated in favor of long term survival. In addition, it was stated in the case study that Tabitha refused treatment because of being fed up in the hospital and due to the unpleasant effects of treatment. According to the ANMC National Competency Standards for the Registered Nurse Section 2.4 (2008), nurses advocate for the rights of the individuals/groups within health care institution and management through identification of resources to meet insufficient care, communication to meet care needs, and facilitating informed decisions (p. 3). Thus, if the nurse can communicate effectively with Tabitha and can identify resources to address feeling of being fed up in the hospital and the unpleasant effects of treatment, Tabitha can be allowed to make some decisions in terms of her health to facilitate autonomous decision. Finkelman & Kenner (2010) define beneficence as the act of doing something good and caring for the patient (p. 197). The next round of chemotherapy that Tabitha will undergo will lengthen her chance of survival from three months to two years. ANMC (2008) stated that it is the nurses’ responsibility to provide comprehensive, safe, and effective evidence-based nursing care based on predetermined plan of care and achievement of short and long term goals (p. 5-6). Following Tabitha’s refusal to chemotherapy will not be inclined to nurses’ provision of safe care as evidence suggested that refusal of the treatment leads to shortening of survival rate. The nurse and other members of the health care team should provide comprehensive care by offering Tabitha other treatment modalities aside from chemotherapy in order to promote the common good of Tabitha. Non-maleficence means doing no harm and safeguarding the patient (Finkelman & Kenner, 2010, 197). In Tabitha’s case study, the decision to uphold or withhold chemotherapy has a two-fold effect. Upholding chemotherapy will not cause harm to Tabitha and will lengthen her chance of survival but chemotherapy has unpleasant effects and initiating without patient’s permission does not reflect safeguarding of patient’s right. On the other hand, withholding treatment in respect of Tabitha’s autonomy safeguards the patient’s right but may cause harm such as shortening of survival rate. The nurse should communicate to minor patients and their families the benefits and risks of every nursing intervention and must clarify individual/group refusal to care or treatment with other members of the health care team (ANMC, 2008, 3). Justice is the ethical principle that relates to treating people fairly (Finkelman & Kenner, 2010, 197). In healthcare, justice is often applied to situations where a few healthcare resources are to be allocated fairly to a number of people needing care. In this case study, Tabitha has no problems in terms of healthcare resources. In fact, Tabitha was scheduled for chemotherapy but refused to receive the treatment. According to the ANMC National Competency Standards for the Registered Nurse Section 6.1 (2008), a nurse determines priority health needs based on assessment of individual/group needs, preferences, and intervention (p. 5). Therefore, justice on allocation of health needs is served if needs, preferences, and interventions are agreed by both parties. Ethical Conflicts Autonomy vs. Beneficence. As a patient, Tabitha may have the right to an autonomous decision in matters related to her welfare and care treatment. She has the right to refuse treatment and suffer the consequences, provided that an informed decision has been made. However, conflict of autonomy arises because Tabitha’s decision to refuse chemotherapy may compromise her safety and the good outcome of prolonging survival to approximately two years. According to Hanson et al. (2005), children, minors, and young adults have the right to participate in their own care; however, parents or guardians have also the right to be involved in different aspects of patient care due to legal and moral responsibility (p. 14). Tabitha’s families were very supportive of her decision to withdraw treatment; therefore, beneficence is not being applied. Autonomy vs. Non-maleficence. In an intent to do no harm, members of the healthcare team told Tabitha and her parents that the next round of chemotherapy is needed for a 30% chance of survival for possibly 2 years. As she may have the right to refuse certain interventions or treatment, the nurse following the consent and order may find it in contrary to the principle of non-maleficence or doing no harm. Aside from patients’ rights, nurses promote the health of the patients and protect their safety. With knowledge that treatment refusal will shorten Tabitha’s survival to three months, the nurse is fully aware that the intent to do no harm was not followed; instead, the autonomy of the patient is upheld in the case study. Consider the Law Consent is an aspect of the law that defends healthcare professionals from acts related to assault, battery, or false imprisonment (Staunton & Chiarella, 2008, 112). The ANMC (2008) Competency Standards for the RN states that nurses “practice in accordance with legislation by complying with relevant legislation and common law, fulfilling duty of care, and recognizing and responding appropriately to unsafe or unprofessional nursing practice (p. 2). As consent is an essential medical care, healthcare professionals must be knowledgeable of the Department’s policy on consent. Staunton and Chiarella (2008) define consent as the agreement between two parties that requires a level of common understanding (p. 116). Consent can be given on an implied, verbal, or written basis and must be considered as valid. Tabitha is under the legal age requirement that is necessary to legally acknowledge her decision to refuse treatment but there are also other issues that need to be considered such as her right as a patient, mental capacity, health status, and parental involvement in decision-making. According to the Age of Majority Act 1972 (WA) a person has to be 18 years old and above to assume full legal capacity; however, the Consent to Treatment policy for WA outlined that a patient is capable of giving informed consent when she has full understanding of the things required by the Division, matters involved in the decision, and the effect of giving consent (Department of Health, 2009, 52). In addition, consent is also highly regarded in oncology treatments and procedures. Accountability in nursing practice is a must, especially when it comes to consent. The Council of Australian Governments signed an Intergovernmental Agreement for a National Registration and Accreditation Scheme for the Health Professions that requires all registered health practitioners to report other registered health practitioner who has a notifiable conduct or behavioral conduct that may cause public harm (Bird, 2010, 593). Therefore, under the Australian law, it is not only the doer of the action who is accountable if mistakes are made in obtaining in obtaining consent but the other registered health practitioner who is aware of the faults and failed to report the incidence. Ethical Decision Tabitha’s condition would deteriorate if chemotherapy will not be performed. On the contrary, insisting her to go onto treatment would violate her right to autonomy and eventually might create distress with the patients as Tabitha wishes to have a peaceful and dignified end to her life. According to ANMC (2008) National Competency Standards for the Registered Nurse, a nurse who practiced within the professional and ethical nursing framework acknowledges the dignity, culture, values, beliefs and rights of individuals/groups, including the refusal to care and treatment (p. 3). Allowing Tabitha not to receive chemotherapy does not violate the competency standards of a registered nurse to provide a quality and safe care because upholding the patient’s consent in relation to care, comfort, dignity, and alleviation of pain and suffering is the highest quality nursing care a nurse could offer to the patients (ANMC, 2008, 1). Therefore, it is ethically acceptable to uphold Tabitha’s right to refuse to treatment. Legally, Tabitha is also entitled to decide on her own care. It was stated earlier that under the Consent to Treatment policy for WA, young adult like Tabitha can decide to accept or refuse treatment when she demonstrates competence and understanding of medical condition and consequence of treatments. In the case study, Tabitha has shown maturity and understanding with respect to treatment decisions and has been informed of the consequences of refusing the chemotherapy. Added to these, families expressed their support towards Tabitha’s decision which is also essential in making decision related to care. Therefore, Tabitha’s decision to refuse chemotherapy is considered legal under the Australian law. References ANMC. (2005). National competency standards for the registered nurse. Retrieved on May 18, 2012 from http://www.anmc.org.au/userfiles/file/competency_standards/Competency_standards_RN.pdf Bird, S. (2010). Mandatory reporting of health practitioners: notifiable conduct. Australian Family Physician, 39(8): pp. 593-594. Retrieved on May 18, 2012 from http://www.racgp.org.au/afp/201008/201008bird.pdf Daniels, R. & Nicoll, L. (2012). Cancer Management. Contemporary Medical-Surgical Nursing (2nd ed.) (p. 313-351). Melbourne: Cengage Learning Australia. Daniels, R. & Nicoll, L. (2012). Complementary and Alternative Therapies. Contemporary Medical-Surgical Nursing (2nd ed.) (p. 299-313). Melbourne: Cengage Learning Australia. Department of Health. (2009). Policy for the Western Australian Health System. Retrieved on May 18, 2012 from http://www.health.wa.gov.au/circularsnew/attachments/404.pdf Finkelman, A. & Kenner, C. (2010). Ethics and Legal Issues. Professional Nursing Concepts: Competencies for Quality Leadership (p. 195-216). Massachusetts: Jones and Bartlett Learning LLC. Hanson, S. et al. (2005). Applying the Standards to special needs populations. Standards for Providing Quality Palliative Care for all Australians (p. 14-17). Australian Capital Territory: Palliative Care Australia. New South Wales Department of Health. (2005). Specific Issues. Guidelines for end-of-life care and decision-making (p. 12-14). New South Wales: Better Health Centre – Publications Warehouse. Porth, C.M. (2010). Neoplasia. Essentials of Pathophysiology: Concepts of Altered Health States (3rd ed.) (p. 131-158). New South Wales: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins. Staunton, P. & Chiarella, M. (2008). Consent to Treatment. Nursing and the Law (6th ed.) (p. 112-135). New South Wales: Elsevier Australia. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Patient Diagnosed With Cancer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words”, n.d.)
Patient Diagnosed With Cancer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/nursing/1451522-assignment-case-study-answer
(Patient Diagnosed With Cancer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words)
Patient Diagnosed With Cancer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1451522-assignment-case-study-answer.
“Patient Diagnosed With Cancer Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1750 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/nursing/1451522-assignment-case-study-answer.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Patient Diagnosed With Cancer

Patient Scenario: Diagnosed with Prostate Cancer

The physical examination for prostate cancer has two main components, namely Digital Rectal examination (DRE) and measuring blood levels of Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA).... The physical examination for prostate cancer has two main components, namely Digital Rectal examination (DRE) and measuring blood levels of Prostate Specific Antigen (PSA).... However, in prostate cancer, the levels in blood rise very high which the guide further examination like prostate biopsy....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Treatment of Diseases through Improved Diagnostic Techniques

For instance, diseases like cancer, HIV/AIDS and diabetes.... Diseases like cancer and the HIV/AIDS virus are on the rise all over the globe and improved diagnostic techniques have led to the doctors, the patients and the whole society understanding the treatment of the diseases as these require a community's responsibility.... cancer kills a large number of people in the world annually.... The main types of cancers on the rise include breast cancer, prostate cancer, lung cancer and cervical cancer....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Cancer and Cancer Treatments

In the past, many believed the best treatment for cancer patients included rest and reduced physical activity; however, today, as more research is being conducted, many are finding and figuring out the various health benefits connected to engaging in physical activity within those who are diagnosed with chronic diseases.... Therefore, in comparison to previous recommendations for those diagnosed with chronic diseases, participating in certain physical activities can bring about many advantages and benefits for cancer patients....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Population-Specific Pain Assessment & Management

It is estimated that one third of patients diagnosed with cancer will experience moderate to severe pain on diagnosis with another two thirds experiencing pain with advanced disease (Woodruff, 1996).... 5 million people diagnosed with cancer each year suffer cancer-related pain on a daily basis.... Pain is one of the most common, and certainly the most feared, symptoms associated with advanced cancer.... The job of the cancer-screening test is to determine which patients should be biopsied....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Patient Orientation Program for Patients Diagnosed with Cancer in Organization

Research has Why an organization should implement an in-person group facilitated patient orientation program for patients diagnosed with cancer?... Having cancer is a stressful event in any patients life.... Research has shown that such stress of the potential patients attending in an outpatient cancer clinic can be amplified by several factors experienced in such clinics.... If an intervention can be designed and implemented which can alleviate this stress of first-time visit to a outpatient cancer clinic, it could be instrumental in generating better patient outcome and client satisfaction which may align to the organizational goal of providing quality care to such patients through measures which have positive benefits over costs incurred (Gallant and Coutts, 2003)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Palliative Care: Reflective Media of Laurie Strike

Having fulfilled his family obligations, he feels that he has no reason to live and ask his family to support his decision to have his life cancer is an incurable condition that is growingly becoming common among the elderly people as well as a bigger segment of the population.... With early diagnosis and timely intervention, the patient's quality of life can be gratefully improved.... The family is the immediate primary care giver that should be listed in the care of the patient; it forms a useful link in the provision of service in palliative care....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Treatment of Diseases through Improved Diagnostic Techniques

iseases like cancer and the HIV/ AIDS virus are on the rise all over the globe and improved diagnostic techniques have led to the doctors, the patients and the whole society understanding the treatment of the diseases as these happen to be a community's responsibility.... he role of improvement in diagnosis procedures is mainly to provide the patient's safety.... Cases of patients dying due to the wrong diagnoses are familiar to many whereby the correct disease is discovered when it is in its final and most severe stage and no treatment whatsoever could save the patient and this leads to death....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Health Services Administration

The author of the following paper highlights that during the course of life and illness trajectory, there are instances when an individual is diagnosed with a life-limiting ailment thus can only be managed through palliative care (O'Neill, 2005).... hellip; Palliative care is an approach that improves the quality of life of the patient and the families facing the life-limiting problem and the treatment of pain and other physical problems.... In palliative care, care of the terminally ill patients is provided by an interdisciplinary team and offered in conjunction with other appropriate forms of health care treatment for an ultimate benefit to the patient and the community (Quill & Abernethy, 2013)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us