StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
Plea bargain involves offering concessions in sentences and charges to encourage defendants to plead guilty and surrender their constitutional right of a jury trial. In operation, defendants who opt to exercise their right to a jury trial are deterred by fear of more prolonged…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation"

Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation number Publish Introduction Plea bargain involves offering concessions in sentences and charges to encourage defendants to plead guilty and surrender their constitutional right of a jury trial. In operation, defendants who opt to exercise their right to a jury trial are deterred by fear of more prolonged sentences and severe charges; consequently, 95% of defendants normally prefer plea-bargaining (Grossman & Katz, 1983). Empirical research has revealed that higher crime levels and greater social emphasis on punishing guilty offenders leads to more plea-bargaining.

As opposed to this, lower crime rate and greater social emphasis on not punishing innocent offenders’ leads to avoidance of plea-bargaining.GuiltyPlea bargaining is seen to let ‘professional’ criminals get off the hook too easily as they are familiar with the criminal justice system (Miceli, 1996). There are evident advantages for guilty offenders to opt for plea bargain as it significantly reduces their sentence as per the Sentencing Guidelines Council (2007) despite convincing evidence.

Similarly, imprisonment may be substituted by alternatives such as home detention, probation period, or community service and even immediate release. Sexual offenders can greatly benefit by pleading guilty to violent behaviour instead of sexual charges that would save them from public registration, special discharge terms, and restricted parole conditions. A defendant who is found guilty of a serious felony in a jury trial on average receives a prison sentence twice of that offered in plea bargain for the same crime (Soni & McCann, 1996).

The point of time in a trial when a defendant negotiates plea bargain is critical as it significantly affects sentencing. The Runciman Report demonstrated how knowledgeable criminals use plea bargain to their advantage when they are certain of the verdict, which ensues in a cracked trial (Runciman, 1993).InnocentCriminal justice systems based on plea bargain subtly rob defendants of their constitutional rights simply on the excuse of lack of time or money to listen. In reality, plea bargaining creates unconstitutional conditions and exerts impermissible burden on a variety of chief constitutional liberties (Baker & Mezzetti, 2001).

In consideration of this, Justice Powell contended (OHear, 2007):“the implementation of a strategy calculated solely to deter the exercise of constitutional rights is not a constitutionally permissible exercise of discretion.”Plea bargain deprives the defendant of three fundamental rights protected by Fifth and Sixth Amendments, namely, the right of jury trial, self-incrimination, and confronting hostile witnesses. Weak cases are more likely to enter into plea bargains, as it is difficult to determine guilt or convict defendants.

Another motivation for innocent defendants to accept plea bargain is when they are unable to raise bail and are forced to live in jail or detention. Since, it can take years from a trial to be initiated, so instead choosing plea bargain is most likely to lead to a shorter sentence (Png, 1986). Statistics have revealed that 56% innocent defendants pleaded guilty to avoid official quasi-legal procedures, uncertainty, personal plans, care-taking responsibilities, and similar issues.ConclusionIn light of the arguments presented above, I would take a plea bargain early in the trial if my defence counsel assured me that the burden of proof was too high.

Alternatively, I would sit out and wait for the right time to plea bargain in case that my defence counsel told me that the burden of proof was weak or perhaps circumstantial. This position would stand true whether I am charged with a heinous or a non-heinous crime. In addition, it is clear that the real loser of reduced sentences due to plea bargains is naive offenders who fear and mistrust the judicial system due to their inexperience. The more experienced offenders learn to bank on the system to derive whatever possible benefit through plea bargaining.

ReferencesBaker, S., & Mezzetti, C. (2001). Prosecutorial Resources, Plea Bargaining, and the Decision to Go to Trial. Journal of Law Economics Organization 17(1) , 149-167.Grossman, G. M., & Katz, M. L. (1983). Plea Bargaining and Social Welfare. American Economic Review 73(4) , 749-757.Miceli, T. J. (1996). Plea Bargaining and Deterrence: An Institutional Approach. European Journal of Law and Economics 3(3) , 249-264.OHear, M. M. (2007). The End of Bordenkircher extending the logic of Apprendi to Plea Bargaining.

Washington University Law Review 84 , 835-849.Png, I. P. (1986). Optimal Subsidies and Damages in the Presence of Judicial Error. International Review of Law and Economics 6 , 101-105.Runciman, V. (1993). The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice Report. London: The Stationery Office (TSO).Soni, A., & McCann, M. E. (1996). Guilty Pleas. Georgetown Law Journal 84 , 1039.

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation Essay - 9”, n.d.)
Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation Essay - 9. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1613540-forensic-psychology-and-criminal-investigation
(Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation Essay - 9)
Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation Essay - 9. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1613540-forensic-psychology-and-criminal-investigation.
“Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation Essay - 9”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1613540-forensic-psychology-and-criminal-investigation.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Forensic Psychology and Criminal Investigation

How Other Disciplines Could Replace Forensic Psychology

Clinical psychology and its investigations and evacuations are detailed.... Name: Course: Lecturer: Date: Topic: The extent to which other disciplines could replace forensic psychology disciplines for instance, clinical psychology The field of forensic psychology deals with law and psychology.... One, forensic psychology is limited in scope compared to clinical psychology.... forensic psychology is limited towards law and crime; the findings are aimed at making sound judgments on criminals and evaluating the court proceedings on special cases like children (Earl 90)....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Professional EthicsRole and Importance

Due to dynamism, psychologist have advocated for use of psychology in legal matters, professional and institutional… This thus has necessitated the inception and use of forensic psychology in the field of criminal investigation, clinical practice, legal affairs and also as a profession (Weiner, 2006). My area of discussion Understanding the Concepts al Affiliation) Psychology is an art and practice that has been applied since it was realized that it had a practical contribution in to some essential aspects in everyday life....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Field Notes and Reports

Field notes and reports are very crucial in a criminal investigation; they offer a short record of occurrences, moments, situations, suspects, eyewitnesses, and extra information in writing.... The… Field notes are more dependable than a human's memory, as they can be utilized as a basis of certain information and aspects that are forgettable (Schroeder, & Field s and Reports al Affiliation Introduction Field s and reports are very crucial in a criminal investigation; they offer a short record of occurrences, moments, situations, suspects, eyewitnesses, and extra information in writing....
2 Pages (500 words) Essay

Criterion for Criminal Psychopathological Profiling

There are many techniques of criminal activities and criminal psychopathology is certainly one of the techniques.... The paper "Criterion for criminal Psychopathological Profiling" discusses that psychopathological criminals falling in inhibited class are shy and have the tendency of dragging their victims deep into a very secrete place where they execute their criminal intentions.... criminal psychopathology, which is the basis of this study, is an extension of criminal intelligence that tends to consider certain crimes as results of mental disorders imminent in a given criminal....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Paper

Usefulness of Hypnosis as a Tool to the Police

It is a procedure that performed by a trained person (forensic hypnotic, psychiatrist, or a trained police officer).... 45-67). forensic hypnosis has been around for a while.... In professional issues side, the big concern has been the qualifications that a forensic hypnotic should have to be able to perform the procedure.... In the event forensic hypnosis becomes an option, a decision will need to be made on whom to perform the procedure (Schreider et al....
3 Pages (750 words) Essay

Formulating a Research Question

Crime scene staging is the act of purposeful alteration of a crime or crime scene with the motive of misleading the… Factually, crime scene staging is a recognized occurrence in forensic psychology and legal systems, in addition to the criminal justice systems.... Factually, crime scene staging is a recognized occurrence in forensic psychology and legal systems, in addition to the criminal justice systems.... forensic psychology involves the use of psychology professionalism and science in countering issues related to crimes and the legal system (Towl & Crighton, 2010)....
1 Pages (250 words) Assignment

Crime Scene Staging

Journal of Police and criminal Psychology.... The first category is defined as the intentional altering of evidence or offering false information to the law officials with intent to misdirect the investigation from the real facts.... The main objective of their article is to offer insights into the major categories of staged crimes....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Inferences Based on Phrasing and Behavioral Investigative Advice

This assignment "Inferences Based on Phrasing and Behavioral Investigative Advice" discusses that the proper choice of words and phrases is critical for the correct interpretation of likely occurrences in behavioral investigative advice.... nbsp;The messages conveyed are based on probability and certainty....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us