StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Analysis of Property Law Case - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
"Analysis of Property Law Case" paper focuses on the case where there is a right to occupation of a matrimonial home however under the Family Act, a spouse can make a charge on the legal interest of the other spouse and if it is real estate, a charge on unregistered land will be a Class F charge. 
 
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.1% of users find it useful
Analysis of Property Law Case
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Analysis of Property Law Case"

Property Law There is a right to occupation of a matrimonial home1 however under the Family Act, a spouse can make a charge on the legal interest of the other spouse and if it is real estate, a charge on unregistered land will be a Class F charge. Since Annie Crane has registered a Class F charge on the property, there is a need to examine whether the land has been properly registered at all. The existence of a DII land charge further suggests that the land is not registered.2 There is the possibility of existence of a restrictive covenant on the land could be binding on the successors, in this case, Mr. Crane Jr, because a covenant on registered land would be registered as well and not require a DII charge. The details of the charge need careful examination to determine any existing prior rights. Bearing these aspects in view, the existence of a CI land charge suggests that Mr. Crane’s right in the property may be in the nature of an equitable charge that is acquired by a tenant or statutory owner for life.3 There have been successive charges over this land, hence applying section 97 of the Property Act of 1925, any puisne mortgage existing in Mr. Crane’s favor will be determined by the order of registration, however the Land Charges Act4 would make such a mortgage void where a subsequent purchaser of the property is concerned. However, since Mr. Crane has registered the property and the deed exists, this problem may be averted. Ms. Chandra: Section 53(1) of the now-repealed Law of Property Act of 1925 had clarified that no oral interests can be created in property. However Section 53(2) included the provision for the existence of a constructive trust arising in those cases where a former co-habitee asserts a beneficial interest arising out of an informal arrangement, such as that Ms. Chandra had with Mr. Crane, in providing funds for improvement of the property from her own savings. The Land Registration Act of 2002 which has replaced the Law of property Act of 1925 also includes a formality requirement of a signature, even for documents in the prescribed electronic format that are “to be regarded for the purpose of any enactment” as a deed.5 Ms. Chandra’s interest is not a legal one and may not fall under the category of protection of land charges.6 This could have entitled her to a second legal charge over the land, which would have been enforceable even in the cases of unregistered land, where the charge has not been registered as a class C1 charge7. She has been cohabiting with Mr. Crane and there is no special law that applies in the case of property shared by cohabitees, although the Law Commission has recommended property rights for separating cohabiting couples on par with divorcing married couples8. Beneficial interests are to be determined by considering the intentions of the parties at the time of purchase rather than by subsequent events9, hence Ms. Chandra’s contribution to the property from her savings, which has also elevated the value of the property, may be considered by the Courts as a ground for the existence of a constructive trust. Lord Justice Grant stated in the case of Grant v Edwards10 that when a party has not made a contribution to the purchase price and no written agreement exists, the party must demonstrate that a common intention existed for a beneficial interest to ensue. Ms. Chandra may have to demonstrate that such a common intention existed and the Courts have generally looked to the expenditures incurred on the house which may demonstrate common intention11. However, since she has given up her tenancy and put all her savings into the property and may be entitled to a beneficial share12 in the proceeds of the sale in accordance with her investments in accordance with the principle that was established in the case of Oxley v Hiscock.13 The courts have recognized such beneficial rights as being proprietary in nature.14 The Hollies: An easement is therefore an interest in the land which will continue even if ownership of the land changes.15 Easements are also governed by the formality requirements under the Land Registration Act of 2002 and a non compliance with the formality requirements can make an interest invalid and non enforceable16. The written notification in the Deed regarding the easement may suffice to close the old path and formalize the use of the new path, however it must be noted that parking space for the Hollies is very restricted. When a right of way has been granted over a road that is not up to the adoption standards, the person to whom such right of way has been allowed will have the right to undertake further construction to bring the road up to standard.17 Mr. Johnson may have such a right. Moreover, there have been disputes over the years on the issue of access and drainage and the engineers’ report shows that the structural damage caused to the property has arisen due to leaking from the underground drainage system, which has caused the subsidence of the soil. There is also an open manhole and Mr. Crane could be held liable for any expenses arising out of repairs to the Hollies which is over and above the insured amount, due to his failure to attend to the leaking pipes. Where Mr. Brown is concerned, there is no formal written registration of his interest in the property and as stated earlier, the Land Registration Act of 2002 mandates the registration of all interests in property, through the formality requirement, failing which the interest will not be legally enforceable.18 Mr. Brown has been in adverse possession of the basement for six years and since he has been living in it, the conditions to invoke his impregnable possession include physical occupation of the property do exist19. As stated in the case of Powell v McFarlane, “Factual possession signifies an appropriate degree of physical control…….. ……broadly, I think what must be shown as constituting factual possession is that the alleged possessor has been dealing with the land as an occupying owner might have been expected to deal with it.”20 However, possession is no more nine tenths of the law. The freehold owner has the right to oppose a squatter’s claim, because no matter how long the possession of the property, it will not bar the paper owner’s title (in this case Mr. Crane) to the registered land21, because adverse possession itself will no longer constitute ownership if the registered title holders oppose the claim. But it is also necessary to take into consideration the fact that although the Land Registration Act of 2002 has eliminated several overriding interests, this does not include an interest belonging to a person who is in actual occupation of the property. It does appear however that a subsequent purchaser will not be obliged to honor Mr. Brown’s possession of the basement and Mr. Crane may have to request him to leave. Bibliography * Brude-Radcliffe, Godfrey, 2005. “Development and the Law” Taylor and Francis * Clake, Alison and Kohler, Paul, 2005, “Property Law: Commentary and Materials”, Cambridge University Press * “Cohabitation: the financial consequences of relationship breakdown” Law Commission Paper (2007) Cm 7182, January 31, 2008 * Halsbury’s Laws of England. Easements and Profits a prendre (4th edn) para 1-239 Cases cited: * Barclays Bank v Buhr (2001) EWCA Civ 1223 * Burns v Burns (1984) Ch 317 at pp 32H to 329C * Grant v Edwards (1986) Ch 638 646H-647D * Gissing v Gissing (1971) AC 886 * Nationwide Building Society v James Beauchamp (a firm) (2001) EWCA Civ 275 470 * Oxley v Hiscock (2004) EWCA Civ 546 * Powell v McFarlane (1977) 38 P&CR 452 at * Turton v Turton (1988) Ch 542 * Walker v Hall Ch 542 at 554G-555D Read More

 

Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Property law coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Property law coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544281-property-law-coursework
(Property Law Coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Property Law Coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544281-property-law-coursework.
“Property Law Coursework Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1544281-property-law-coursework.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Analysis of Property Law Case

Equity and Trusts: The Perfect Gift

Conceptually, the transfer of any kind of property from one individual to the other is termed as a 'gift' in accordance with the legal propositions.... At the end of the case, the court held a decision that Elena had no possession of any kind of property in the Bank of Louisiana as the title was never handed over to Lord from Medley.... According to the Milroy v Lord case, it has been observed that trust must not be held for the sake of the protection of gifts....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Property Law - Oxley v Hiscock

rust law falls under the broader topic of property law and family law and relates to wills, trusts and property that are shared or distributed.... The paper "property law - Oxley v Hiscock" discusses that Hiscock's appeal was granted as he suggested that judgment be based not on unspecified intention of equal or half shares but according to the proportion of financial contributions made to buy the property.... This analysis is on the Oxley V Hiscock [2004] EWCA Civ 546 case that relates to property law and claims of individuals who cohabit a particular property....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Accounting - Tax Research Case

Over the years, the practice in assortment gave rise to huge uncertainty and court case which has created an extensive body of perplexing and opposing right.... n yet another case of Commissioner v.... he court in the case of Commissioner v.... The most crucial queries in income tax law are with regard to an expenditure incurred in the course of a business....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Issues of Property Rights According to England Law

This case study solves the "Issues of property rights according to England Law".... It defines what rights the parties of the case have and whether the rights are binding upon all of them.... In relation to Peter, it will be necessary to consider the law in relation to overriding interests, in order to establish whether Peter might have an interest in the property.... It considers the scenario both in the event that the property is an unregistered title and a registered title....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study

The Analysis of the Property Law on Land

The paper "The Analysis of the property law on Land" explains that the case under study is Kernott v Jones which was before the English court in 2011.... The court imputes intention after an analysis of the dealings between the parties in the dispute.... The case pitted Mr Kernott and Ms Jones, who met in 1980.... The decision made in this case has cleared up the uncertainties in law with regard to family home trusts.... The matter in question was share quantification in a property jointly purchased and registered in the names of a couple that lived together without expressly declaring the beneficial interests due to both....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Property Law Cases

This paper "property law Cases" discusses the area of law that claims for beneficial interests in land under an implied trust is inherently complex, further compounded by judicial categorization of trusts into resulting and constructive trusts.... In particular, I will undertake a contextual analysis in reference to a growing body of case law in relation to implied trusts on the breakdown of family relationships and consider whether there is any real distinction between resulting trusts and constructive trusts as applied by the judiciary....
5 Pages (1250 words) Assignment

Analysis of Property Law Cases

"analysis of property law Cases" paper states that legal interests in another person's unregistered land such as a mortgage, legal leaseholds are, in the main, automatically effective against the land over which they exist, even if not granted by the current landowner.... Under s 27(2) of Law of property Act 1925, overreaching will apply where there is two or more trustee or a trust corporation and the purchase money is paid over to both of them.... The son and daughter-in-law were registered as owners....
6 Pages (1500 words) Assignment

Liability Insurance Policy

The paper "Liability Insurance Policy" is an outstanding example of an essay on finance and accounting.... The insurance policies are businesses are created around liabilities, a liability is considered a burden that one has to bear in the event of a loss.... Liability insurance is a fundamental aspect of everyday business operations because of the numerous risks that people face in the course of work....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us