StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

The Sale of Goods within the Internal Market - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "The Sale of Goods within the Internal Market" describes that it would be advisable for William to undertake the inspection, especially if other manufacturers within Italy. Since this involves the issue of public health and safety, it is likely to be deemed justified…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER92.7% of users find it useful
The Sale of Goods within the Internal Market
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "The Sale of Goods within the Internal Market"

Case Scenario The case of William is one which will specifically invoke Articles 28 and 29 of the EC Treaty which regulates the sale of goods within the internal market. Article 14(2) of the EC states that the internal market comprises “an area without frontiers” within the European Union, where there is to be free movement of goods and people. Article 28 states that “quantitative restrictions on imports and all measures having equivalent effect” are to be prohibited. However Article 30 qualifies these restrictions by stating that on grounds of public health, public morality or public security, restrictions may be permissible. The moot question that arises in William case’s is whether the requirements spelt out by the Italian Government for import of his cheese into Italy could constitute a violation of Article 28 and therefore a restriction on imports? Their first requirement is (a) an inspection test to determine the listeria content of the cheese (b) a requirement that William change the label on his product. The meaning of quantitative restrictions was clearly stated in the case of Riseria Luigi Geddo v Ente Nazionale Risi1 in which it was stated that “any measure which amounts to a total or partial restraint on imports, exports or goods in transit constitutes a quantitative restriction.” For example, a quota system was held to be a restriction of trade in the case of Salgoil SpA v Italian Minister for Foreign Trade.2 Directive 70/50 must also be taken into consideration because it lists out all measures which are equivalent to quantitative restrictions, however in William’s case, there are certain existing EU Directives which member States are expected to comply with, which will also be relevant. The EU Directives which will apply in the case of William is Directive 92/46/EEC, which has held that listeria must be absent in 1 gm of hard cheese, however in soft cheese it must be absent in 25g samples taken from the product3. Also, the Directive 93/43/EEC is intended to ensure that all food products sold within the EU meet certain minimum health standards. Therefore, under this Directive, it may be noted that any requirements of the Italian Government on the inspections for listeria in the cheese will be only indistinctly applicable4, because it applies to cheeses produced within Italy and outside the country. Since manufacturers within Italy are also expected to comply with this requirement of inspection at their own cost, it is unlikely that that this will qualify as a measure that infringes Article 28. Moreover, Article 3 of Directive 70/50 clearly qualifies that indistinctly applicable measures will infringe Article 28 only if there are restrictive in excess, which is not the case here. The Italian Government’s requirement that the cheese should pass inspection is also justified under Article 30 of the EC treaty which holds the protection of public health as one of the measures which will justify restrictions in imports. There are two rules spelt put in the case of Cassis De Dijon5 which must be applied to William’s case. This case held that certain measures to restrict imports may be justified on grounds of protection of public health and other safety measures, which are deemed to be mandatory requirements. According to this principle - the rule of reason: “Obstacles to movement within the Community ….. relating to marketing of the products in question must be accepted in so far as…….recognized as being necessary to satisfy mandatory requirements….protection of public health, fairness of commercial transactions and the defence of the customer.” This is the first Cassis principle – the rule of reason, which was applied in the case of Cinéthèque SA6 where a restriction was deemed mandatory by the State for cultural activities7, Commission v Denmark (Re Disposable Beer Cans)8 where a restriction on import was justified on the basis of protection of the environment and Oebel.9 Therefore, the initial conclusion that may be drawn in William’s case is that the restriction by the Italian Government on grounds of listeria inspection will qualify under this rule of reason as not being restrictive, since it has been deemed to be necessary in the interest of public health. However the Commission also extended this principle in the rule of recognition that it set out in the same case, as follows: “There is no reason why, provided that [goods]have been lawfully produced and marketed in one of the member states,[ they] should not be introduced into any other member State.”10 Applying this rule, it may be noted that when William has been selling the cheese lawfully within the UK, there is no justifiable reason why they should not be introduced into Italy. Although the requirement for the listeria inspection is a valid requirement if it is also applicable to others within Italy, any restriction on its import would involve national measures on selling arrangements. The ECJ has already demonstrated its reluctance to be involved in such cases.11 On an overall basis therefore, William does have the option to contest the requirement for mandatory inspection of the cheese for listeria before import into Italy. He can contest on the grounds that it is already selling within the U.K. But since there is an EU Directive that exists which specifically mandates inspection of the cheese to determine listeria content, it is likely that William will be expected to comply with the requirement of the Italian Government. However it is possible that the Italian Government’s requirements on labeling may be held to be unjustified and illegal. In the case of Commission v UK12 a requirement that mandated origin marking was deemed a violation of Article 28, and this was also the case in FIETJE13. To restrict William from importing his product into Italy on grounds of its resembling another product would not be one among mandatory requirements and would therefore not be effective. However the requirement that it pass listeria inspection may hold good, in spite of the fact that the cheese is already selling within the U.K., since the European Directive must be mandatorily complied with by the States. Hence, it would be advisable for William to undertake the inspection, especially if other manufacturers within Italy are also required to do so. Since this involves the issue of public health and safety, it is likely to be deemed justified. However, he can certainly contest the restriction on import based upon labeling, since the requirement to change labeling has nothing to do with the quality or quantity of information it contains, rather the restriction is being imposed on the basis of similarity with an existing product which is not an enforceable reason. Bibliography * Case 207/83, Commission v UK * Case 27/80, FIETJE * Case 120/78 Cassis De Dijon * Case 8/74 Dassonville * Cinéthèque SA (Case 60 & 61/84) [1985] ECR * Commission v Denmark (Re Disposable Beer Cans) (Case 302/86) [1988] ECR 4607 * Keck and Mithouard (Cases C–267 & 268/89). * Oebel (Case 155/80) (1981) ECR 1993 * Riseria Luigi Geddo v Ente Nazionale Risi (Case 2/73) [1973] ECR 865 * Salgoil SpA v Italian Minister for Foreign Trade (Case 13/68) [1968] ECR 453 * Torfaen BC v B & Q (Case 145/88) (1989) ECR 3851 * “The European Union Directives” Vermont Cheese Council [online] available at: www.vtcheese.com/vtcheese/rawmilk_files/rawmilk4.html Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“European law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
European law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1536709-european-law
(European Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
European Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1536709-european-law.
“European Law Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/miscellaneous/1536709-european-law.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF The Sale of Goods within the Internal Market

Importance of Information Technology in Marketing

imilar trends were also seen within the business environment of the UK (Wierenga, and Bruggen, 2000, p.... International marketers are also making good use of IT along with effective marketing strategies to compete effectively in the global market.... Advancement in technology has provided the companies with the capability to collect an enormous quantity of information related to the recent and potential market.... Nowadays IT links the marketing and functional equivalents, so as to offer accessibility to market information....
14 Pages (3500 words) Essay

Wal-Mart Marketing Audit

the world's largest retailer, may expand into Russia within the next two years to capitalize on a swelling economy and a dearth of competitors may be taken place (Ermakova, 2008).... It should follow different strategies to keep the present customer and introduce a new market.... The study analyzes the environmental aspects including customers, market and stakeholders with respect to Wal-Mart.... The study also intends to discover the wide-ranging market coverage of Wal-Mart and its popularity to the customers for improved services in the case of household commodities....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Sales Developing and Merchandising

This paper "Sales Developing and Merchandising" focuses on the fact that in the modern business milieu, aspects that range from online marketing, superior product differentiation, apt management strategies, and the use of resources among others have created a competitive platform in the market.... In essence, the nature of products and services offered to form a fundamental basis in which the organization creates its market niche.... The larger the market niches the more the revenues....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Public Health Checks in Sweden

The question that must be posed therefore is whether the requirement under Finnish law is valid and sustainable under Community law that needs to allow for the free movement of goods within the European Union.... ane's mail-order business:Finnish law allows the sale of blood pressure monitors only in pharmacies, therefore in effect, it is indirectly favoring Finnish manufacturers who will find it easier to transport and market the goods by placing them in pharmacies, as opposed to companies from other countries....
8 Pages (2000 words) Case Study

Nestle UK - Internal and External Analysis

The paper 'Nestle UK - internal and External Analysis' is a bright example of a management report.... The paper 'Nestle UK - internal and External Analysis' is a bright example of a management report.... The paper 'Nestle UK - internal and External Analysis' is a bright example of a management report....
10 Pages (2500 words) Report

The Increased Popularity of Social Media

Increased internet development has enhanced the utilization of social media platforms within the marketing strategies developed by companies.... The utilization of social media is vital in the brand awareness campaign as it enhances the rapid growth of consumer knowledge pertaining to the brand within the market.... herefore, social media identifies a favorable outlet that enhances the product's brand awareness levels within the market through maintaining increased activities on the sites, which encourage the provision of customer feedback and consequent growth of the market share....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Amazon - External and Internal Audit

It includes fine-tuning all the elements of the marketing mix to specific needs for the purposes of satisfying a distinctive target market.... The paper "Amazon - External and internal Audit" is an outstanding example of a marketing case study.... The paper "Amazon - External and internal Audit" is an outstanding example of a marketing case study.... The paper "Amazon - External and internal Audit" is an outstanding example of a marketing case study....
20 Pages (5000 words) Case Study

Implementing and Maintaining Internal Control

the internal control process should ensure that all the laid down policies and communication objectives are met.... the internal control process should ensure that all the laid down policies and communication objectives are met.... the internal control process should ensure that all the laid down policies and communication objectives are met.... Furthermore, the internal control procedures must be in the front line, in matters of controls in any corporate organization (Trenery, 15)....
20 Pages (5000 words) Assignment
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us