StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Risk But, Wasnt That a Disaster - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
This paper "Risk? But, Wasn’t That a Disaster?" focuses on the analysis of works of Toft and Reynolds, two very learned risk management analysts. They have also within this article discussed an intelligent approach towards risk estimation and management. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER95.9% of users find it useful
Risk But, Wasnt That a Disaster
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Risk But, Wasnt That a Disaster"

Risk? But, Wasn’t That a Disaster? Tragedies often take place and as a consequence, precious lives are lost. Every disaster is usually followed by an inquiry. These investigations are usually quite detailed for physical catastrophes; however, for major corporate or financial failures examinations are not as comprehensive as the gravity of matter demands. This paper reviews the analysis of works of Toft and Reynolds, two very learned risk management analysts. They have also within this article discussed an intelligent approach towards risk estimation and management. Turner, from his research work and later published book “Man Made Disasters”, establishes that clear patterns can be drawn out of every disaster that takes place due to human negligence (Turner, 1978). These patterns according to him are clearly divisible in six steps. He also argues that humans can do much more than just witness a catastrophe. Similarly, Perrow in his published book “Normal Accidents” mentions that due to the fact that people are incompetent when it comes to ‘handling complexity’ (Perrow, 1984) therefore accidents at composite facilities come by easily. Both, Turner and Perrow’s work is highly regarded, which were only possible due to society’s resolve to find a way to avoid accidents. Turner also points out in his above referred works that usually it is the un-tested innovation that causes the disaster. He refers to accidents at Hixon in 1968 and Summerland in 1973. Moving from physical disasters to corporate ones, the writer talks about the opportunity for isomorphic learning where in firms specialize into a special segment and engineer the best possible way of doing that job. This way significant time is saved as organizations can out source a particular activity and don’t have to spend time to learn it to do the right way. Not only this complex processes can be better performed by the task masters. Errors in these processes are usually human, and therefore learning to deal with infrequent events is what isomorphic learning is all about. Analyzing these disasters one realizes how similar they are at the time of happening. Human errors are seen to be a major player as far as financial disasters is concerned. Therefore, according to the writer there is a severe need to learn from these mistakes, so that such incidents can be avoided. Although the work that the writer of the article has cited from the authors is pretty much credible, however, more supportive work would make the argument stronger. Incorporating research and studies gives a lot of weight to the examination. Disasters, according to Turner, are caused due to various reasons. His thorough analysis characterizes them as follows: 1. When small and large organizations work together on a project. As both use different systems there is always a higher chance that lapses in system can take place. 2. Tasks that are not properly elaborated and seemingly look easier than they really are. 3. revising goals frequently and not communicating them in time, and changing practices 4. out of date regulations 5. employees occupied with their routine work are usually not able to take time out to supervise different out sourced activities Turner and Pidgeon emphasize that complexity of problems compounds as the number of information handlers’ increase as many new views generate as well as variation in information. This is an inherent problem in today’s organizations. Perrow analyzes the problem of Three Mile Island differently. He establishes three important indices which usually form the ground of large scale financial accidents. The first one he refers as ‘familiarity’ is the over-confidence we have and we usually assume that everyone knows as much as we know. Dorner, believes that due to this over-confidence, we do not re-evaluate things in our mind and that incomplete information always is misleading. John Adams categorizes risk into three main categories. Ones that can be assessed base on our personal experiences. Second are the ones that have to be judged on basis of mathematical models and the last are that have to be judged without credible information in conditions of uncertainty. Perrow and later Checkland believe that complexity mainly depends on the size of the organization and while different organizations interact the levels of complexity differs and some of the checks are not there in the lesser complex organizations. Also complexity is dependent on human frailty, and this increases the level of difficulty of a problem. An important method for keeping a check is risk intelligence. Usually, to avoid extra cost budget cuts often target audit costs, which directly affects the monitoring of the financial system. To maintain this monitoring system internal control needs to be made stronger so that surprises can be avoided to the maximum. As far as tight coupling is concerned, organizations in order to conserve important resources both time and money, tries to skim through process, at times bypassing important steps. These in times of crises act as important pointers highlighting the problems. These vital checks should be used if they are in place. If used these can give ample opportunity to analyze and give time for effective reaction. Perrow also points out towards a new culture that is being introduced now, where in instead of tight coupling, we see what is called loose coupling. In such a case, an employee is trained to supervise a particular task but not controlled via culture. This results not only in remote checks but also increases employee’s motivation level. This is effective in a situation where there are complex systems in an organization and detailed paperwork can be costly. Both Perrow and Turner mention that problems don’t emerge all of a sudden. They take their time called incubation time. Checks should be put so that decisions can be taken in time and contingency plans be made. Turner and Perrow both significantly emphasize as trap of false belief. They say people and organization tend to believe things are going right until and unless something badly goes wrong. This also results in more of a surprise towards an incident. They imply that the signs are there all the time but are usually misread. This requires according to him a safety culture where information is checked for correctness, reliability and validity. He finally puts that a good risk management system should be loose coupled. This has to be incorporated into the organizations culture and has to trickle down from the top management. Risk intelligence as the writer puts it is in fact a combination of the factors put forward by Turner and Perrow. They constitute complexity, familiarity, and coupling issues. The work of Turner, Perrow and others recognizes that information gathered should be reliable and valid. Gauging complexity is a personal trait. However, loose coupling needs de-centralized system within the organization. Subsequently, system checks have to be on guard and should not be by passed even in the easiest of situations, let go of the difficult ones. People should realize that others might not have the same information as they have and therefore should always discuss the issue in detail. As far as business is concerned analysis and review should form an important part of the decision-making process. Internal audit and Quality assurance procedures should be adopted and religiously followed. Risk intelligence is more of a proactive approach, i.e., to highlight a problem way before it becomes a disaster. Over-confidence kills and a tradition of self check should be developed into the organizational culture to manage complexity. Questions like “what if” should be more frequent in an organization which is bound to work in a tight coupling mode. Lastly, information should always be cross-validated. There have been a few limitations with the writer, as they usually are and he has mainly taken into consideration the work of Perrow and Turner. There have been a few cultural analyses by Mary Douglas and Karl Dake which can be a part but not direct examples of isomorphic learning. Both Perrow and Turner’s emphasis proves that the points mentioned earlier are significant as they both conducted separate studies. Humans according to the author are inclined to make things better in any given situation. However, lack of information results in wrong decision and thereby insignificant problems turning into major disasters. Finally, as put earlier risk intelligence has more to it than just these few factors as the human dynamics are as wide as are the horizons. The article by Keith has been a comprehensive analysis of both Perrow and Turner’s work and clearly specifying the areas that need to be addressed. It’s a constructive article and fit for publishing. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Risk But, Wasnt That a Disaster Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/management/1534320-please-provide-a-crtical-review-of-the-attached-academic-journal-article
(Risk But, Wasnt That a Disaster Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words)
https://studentshare.org/management/1534320-please-provide-a-crtical-review-of-the-attached-academic-journal-article.
“Risk But, Wasnt That a Disaster Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1250 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/management/1534320-please-provide-a-crtical-review-of-the-attached-academic-journal-article.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Risk But, Wasnt That a Disaster

Do Natural Disasters lead to internal conflict within a country

The natural disasters that have hit the world in recent times are enough to let all and sundry know that these have been catastrophic and have caused immense damage to mankind and property.... hellip; Natural disasters occur suddenly and thus the reason that these create the most anarchy within a region....
4 Pages (1000 words) Essay

Factors Influencing Insurance Decisions

Factors Influencing Insurance Decisions Name: Course: Professor: Institution: City and State: Date: Introduction The decisions to purchase insurance covers are influenced by factors such as the market structure, price of the cover, and underwriting policies.... hellip; A person planning to purchase an insurance cover must consider these factors before making the final decision whether to purchase the policy....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Accounting Information System: Security, Privacy and Other AIS Issues

The researcher gives some recommendations on how to avoid security problems and suggests that the strategic implementation of disaster recovery plan, which is formulated, communicated and updated and executed in place will also help in gaining the control on Accounting Information System during the times of hazards.... And such disaster recovery through various data recovery models will offer the business continuity to the Accounting Information System.... The researcher focuses on analyzing these issues using risk analysis, risk mitigation and data recovery strategies....
13 Pages (3250 words) Essay

Professional and technical communication

It is the largest humanitarian organization in the world.... It does not discriminate in terms of race, religion, nationality or political opinions.... It was founded in 1919 and currently has 186 members… The members comprise of Red Cross and Red Crescent National Societies.... The Red Crescent is used in place of Red Cross in Islamic countries. IFRC aims at promoting and maintaining human dignity and peace throughout the world....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

The United States Army Corps of Engineers

Keeping them informed is one way of doing this, since it facilitates disaster preparedness.... In the implementation of this policy, such populations will be trained on how to ensure their own safety in the event of disaster such as a tornado, hurricane, tsunami or related scenarios.... Continuous flow of information to the risk population will give the people awareness they need to keep them always prepared....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Risk, Crisis and Disaster Management

 This paper "Risk, Crisis and disaster Management" discusses all the problems faced in the business community have shown the need for the distinct business continuity profession.... The paper considers preparing the business to survive in the worst possible situation.... hellip; The business world is growing fast, and there is a need to change with the changing environment....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper

Mitigation of Poverty Disaster: Towards Sustainable Economic Development

This research is being carried out to evaluate and present mitigation of 'poverty disaster': towards sustainable economic development.... This paper illustrates that poverty disaster can be mitigated using effective emergency planning to achieve a sustainable economic development.... hellip; The study leads to the conclusion that poverty disaster is a real menace that is eating up a large population of the society and statistical evidence clearly show that indeed it is a menace that must be taken seriously....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Risk Management Occurred by the Natural Disasters

nbsp; The degree or amount of preparation that goes into each disaster often eventually determines the property and human lives lost in such disaster.... nbsp; This paper shall discuss the disaster management surrounding Typhoon Parma which hit the Philippines last October 2009.... nbsp; It shall assess the disaster based on the different stages of the risk management cycle, explaining what was right and what was wrong during the management of the disaster....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us