StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

International Trade and Labor and Environmental Standards - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "International Trade and Labor and Environmental Standards" discusses that it is increasingly being acknowledged over time that the gap (if any) between trade, labor as well as environment is narrow because the three are actually interrelated in one way or another…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER97.7% of users find it useful
International Trade and Labor and Environmental Standards
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "International Trade and Labor and Environmental Standards"

INTERNATIONAL TRADE AND LABOR AND ENVIRONMENTAL STANDARDS Introduction It is increasingly being acknowledged over time that the gap (if any) between trade, labor as well as environment is narrow because the three are actually interrelated in one way or another. In fact, the relationship between trade, environment as well as labor is so complex that its analysis takes one far beyond just mere debates on whether environmental and labor standards are to be enforced through sanctions in trade and or by trade agreements. Nevertheless, one fact that must be acknowledged is that trade plays a significant positive role through raising living standards of people and hence directly and indirectly affecting labor as well as environmental standards globally. Research studies by such organizations as the World Bank show that trade triggers and supports growth of economies producing growing middle class citizens in the countries (Rose, para 1-7). The two (economic growth as well as middle class population) motivate these countries to uphold environmental conservation and management as well as improve labor standards. This paper therefore intends to conduct a qualitative analysis of facts and features in international trade, labor as well as environmental standards as they are in the current day by use of available literature. Discussion Literature shows that trade agreements in international trade especially by developed and emerging economies promote economic opportunities within the emerging countries, which alleviate living standards of workers within the countries (Neary, 96). The trade agreements by the developed countries like the US provide opportunities for economic performance for indigenous industries as well as workers. Besides, the negotiations of such countries within the international trade front have been associated with improved labor standards within other countries hence the interrelation between trade (international trade), labor and issues of environmental conservation and management. Analysts as well as policy makers take a leading role in the investigating and explaining how international trade interacts with environment. For instance, a very recent debate on whether trade should be liberalized triggered the conclusions that liberalization is likely to cause increased industrial emissions whose effects are detrimental to the general environment. This on the other hand set the platform for discussion on whether tightening environmental and trade policies should be encouraged for compensation of such changes as would result from the policy changes. Besides, there has also been a growing interest in linking environmental policy and regulation efforts as well as international competitiveness especially in trade. Such debates within the European Union have been associated with reduced competitiveness in trade and industrial manufacturing because of heightened environmental regulation. Accordingly, the report by Neary (96) shows that such reduced competitiveness by increased regulation would lead to de-industrialization as well as carbon leakage because polluting industries would physically relocated internationally. This would therefore be detrimental not only to the host country but also to the international community as the effect of environmental pollution is not restricted only within a country’s borders. The effects of such an outcome would be shift of environmental degradation costs and shifting of benefits over industrial agglomeration for the foreign locations. This effect would spill to the society and the individual labor as they are directly influenced by industrial operations within the country. Stringent environmental regulatory frameworks have characterized international trade in the recent past decades. Xu (233-250) carried out an empirical study on the effects of domestic policies as influential to the competitiveness of ESG (environmentally sensitive goods). The time series evidence produced indicate no definite systematic changes for the patterns of trade with ESGs noted within developed economies, which were characterized with increased changes in regulation especially within the 1980s and 1990s after designing and imposition of such strict environmental policies. The application of the test over many countries indicate that more stringent regulations on the environment have no direct cause to reduction in all exports, the exports of ESGs as well as export of non resource based ESGs. This would therefore be interpreted to imply that such stringent trade regulation have no association to trade barriers not only to developed economies but also to the emerging economies. Much of debates on trade have been centered on the effects of domestic policy framework and the effects towards local trade as well as the international trade. The ‘race to bottom’ model has been among other frameworks that have been developed for this particular analysis. This triggers the discussion of whether international trade relations with a country, which has lower environmental standards would influence the domestic country towards lowering its standards through domestic political pressures or otherwise liberalize domestic environmental standards in order to accommodate the domestic industries. Another model to be analyzed is the ‘pollution haven’ hypothesis, which compares the trade relations between countries observing differing environmental standards. The main concern is that of whether the countries governed by lower environmental regulatory framework has a potential of developing comparative advantage over the trade partners who observes stringent standards in environmental management. However, there is another concern on whether the disparity in the standards have any effect on quality and hence competitiveness of the products produced within the low-regulation economies as viewed by the high-regulation countries (Xu 234). Finally, a more sensitive concern that emerges dominantly over this discussion is the possibility of eco-dumping, which has very sensitive repercussions on international trade as well as the environmental management and conservation. The lack of ‘level playing field’ as is the definition of such trade relations between countries with different regulatory frameworks is termed as ‘unfair trade’. These among other fears therefore call for harmonized environmental standards and regulatory framework in order to observe a healthy interaction between countries who are trading partners and who would pursue a common course in management and conservation of the environemnt. The concerns raised have a relation to industrial competitiveness as is basic within international relations especially on trade as influenced by environmental standards. Another sensitive area that has been in analysis over environment is the issue about labor and environmental management. The late twentieth century was characterized by strategic alignment of labor movements and unions with more elaborate efforts being sighted towards labor-environmentalist movements. Silverman (119-130) carried out a study on the sustainability of labor alliances as well as the evolution of ‘international labor environmentalism’. According to the report, trade unionists at the international front have been very conscious on environmental issues and developed frameworks that esteem principles of solidarity, between workers and nature, protecting the health and safety of individual workers, environments as well as communities within which they work. Environmentalists, trade unionists as well as solidarity activists have therefore met the effects of globalization with enthusiasm and this has had political effects between countries and more so the trading collaborates. Intellectual change and political experiences have been shown to have triggered constitution of alliances between labor unions and environmentalists for the common goal towards improved environment management and conservation. This therefore shows the critical role that labor plays towards improving the relationship between humans and the natural world with efforts by labor unions to collaborate with environmentalists towards proper institutions of regulation standards and policies meant to oversee effective and efficient management of natural ecosystems. The intertwining of labor efforts with the efforts by environmentalists to develop labor based sustainable environmental versions have played a critical role in trade relations within many countries with trade unions taking a leading role in environmental management activities (Silverman, 119). The efforts by the UN and other international labor confederations towards issues of environment dates back many decades and have been seen to play a significant role in development and enforcement of international trade and labor standards of environmental management. The issue of ecological management cannot be evaluated independently without incorporating the effects of trade and the policies that have been developed to oversee the management of environment. An industrial operation, which brings together the effects of labor, plays a significant role in dictating the direction the management of ecosystems and the environment at large takes. Besides nations having own frameworks and policies towards holding labor and trade institutions accountable for management of the natural environment, the international community have instituted relevant frameworks, which involve the international trade players as well as labor unions in management of the environment. Sovereign countries therefore ascribe to the mix of frameworks and standards that are relevant in management of the environment and the related effects that affect the ecosystem. It is also acknowledged that many (if not all) countries have distinct government departments that are concerned with ensuring environmental management not only by individual citizens but also by trading entities within the country. Conclusion The discussion above reveals that environmental management practices by individual nations as well as at the international front brings on board concerted efforts by the trading partners as well as by the labor force. Various standards that have been crafted by individual countries as well as at the international level guide in management of international trade, labor as well as the environment. However, understanding the interaction between the three has been aided by evaluating the historical and the current situation as presented by literature. Among other findings that have been made in this report is that the environment, trade as well as labor have some form of intersection and therefore the standards and policies in governing either must be related to the other(s). This is because the concerns of labor are directly related to industrial practices, which on the other hand influences trade practices, not only locally but also internationally. Besides, it is worth noting that environmental management practices takes direct association with industrial manufacturing hence the interrelation between the three factors. Literature by Neary, Xu as well as Silverman has been used within the above analysis in the theme of international trade, labor as well as environmental standards. Works cited Neary, J. P. "International Trade and the Environment: Theoretical and Policy Linkages." Environmental and Resource Economics 33.1 (2006): 95-118. ProQuest. Web. 8 Apr. 2014. Rose, Fred. "Labor-Environmental Coalitions." Working USA 6.4 (2003): 51. ProQuest. Web. 8 Apr. 2014. Silverman, Victor. "Sustainable Alliances: The Origins of International Labor Environmentalism." International Labor and Working Class History 66 (2004): 118-35. ProQuest. Web. 8 Apr. 2014. Xu, Xinpeng. "International Trade and Environmental Regulation: Time Series Evidence and Cross Section Test." Environmental and Resource Economics 17.3 (2000): 233-57. ProQuest. Web. 8 Apr. 2014. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“International trade and labour and environmental standards Essay”, n.d.)
International trade and labour and environmental standards Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1638452-international-trade-and-labour-and-environmental-standards
(International Trade and Labour and Environmental Standards Essay)
International Trade and Labour and Environmental Standards Essay. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1638452-international-trade-and-labour-and-environmental-standards.
“International Trade and Labour and Environmental Standards Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/macro-microeconomics/1638452-international-trade-and-labour-and-environmental-standards.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF International Trade and Labor and Environmental Standards

The Existing Divergence between the Labor Standards

The paper "The Existing Divergence between the Labor standards" discusses that the United Nations was established in 1945 to maintain global peace, to reaffirm faith in fundamental human rights, in dignity and worth of the human person, in the equal rights of men and women and nations large and small.... ne such organization is the International Labour Organization (ILO) that promotes social justice for labourers and aims to elevate the standards of labour rights and practices....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

Global Commodity Chains and Labor Rights

This paper ''Global Commodity Chains and labor Rights'' tells us that over the past few decades, a basic international manufacturing restructuring has been developed.... This essay will take a close look at various debates on global commodity chains and labor rights.... The large retailers and brand-name manufacturers could implement their market power to improve labor standards at the production level by compensating the subcontractors to increase the cost....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Trade Barriers in International Trade

The growth of international trade has reached new dimensions.... They make use of country comparative advantages, encourage specialization and division of labor, expand the size of export markets, and promote efficiency and competitive environment within the region.... The paper "trade Barriers" presents that all over the world a new order has come to prevail in economic terms and that is the promotion of regional economic powers through.... trade barriers have either blurred or fallen through as a result of national policies....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Examine the arguments for and against international labour standard

These factors have stressed the superiority of capital market on labor market.... In capitalist market there is a fear of lowering of the living standard from the competitors in labor market economies.... The condition of Furthermore, the government prohibits in trade union formations amongst work force.... This does not mean that the free trade is a negative approach.... A better socialistic approach needs to be maintained to handle the ill effects of open trade....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Difference between the Labour Standards and Labour Rights

Its main functions are the promotion of social justice, providing vocational training and education, giving special care to women and children laborers, initiation of research in social and labor policies and creation of 'international labor standards for freedom of association, wages, working hours, labor compensation, social insurance, paid vacation, the safety of industrial workers, employment service and labor inspection'.... The paper "Difference between the Labour standards and Labour Rights" states that changes are impacting other practical and normative issues....
14 Pages (3500 words) Assignment

The Benefits of the International Labor Standards

The paper "The Benefits of the International Labor standards" focuses on the standard set by the ILO.... The International Labor standards are a representation of how global agreement to a specific labor issue can become when the problem is discussed at a global level.... The official and permanent headquarter of the ILO is the International labor Office where all the operations are carried out.... The responsibilities of a Director-General include overseeing the efficiency in the demeanor of the International labor Office....
10 Pages (2500 words) Thesis

Possible Trade Restrictions For Improving Environmental Conditions

This paper analyses both sides of the argument and concludes that trade sanctions are entirely unnecessary for forcing compliance with labor and environmental standards.... The reearch "Possible Trade Restrictions For Improving Environmental Conditions" emposes the USA's possible usage of trade restrictions to force compliance with environmental and labor standards.... Positive results are more likely in instances where developing and least developed countries are in a position to compete in the global markets and therefore have the incentive through cooperation to improve environmental and labor standards....
7 Pages (1750 words) Research Proposal

Consequences of Globalization of Labour

This is characterized by independence and interdependency in the entire world to facilitate the efficient transfer of goods, services, capital, and labor across the national frontiers.... Within the globalization of labor, we understand there is movement from developing to develop and vice versa, it is thus interesting to note the effect this will bring to the economic facets.... onsequences of GlobalizationAs indicated in the introductory part, there are several consequences that come with the globalization of labor both positive and negatives....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us