StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Industrial Action in the UK - Essay Example

Summary
This paper 'Industrial Action in the UK ' tells that The past 30years have witnessed the enormous extension of the scope of the economic torts as they affect industrial action, while simultaneously seeing a significant contraction in the breath of the golden formula, a combination of events…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER91% of users find it useful
Industrial Action in the UK
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Industrial Action in the UK"

Extension of Scope of Economic Tort in Industrial Action in UK – “The past 30years have witnessed enormous extension of the scope of the economic torts as they affect industrial action , while simultaneously seeing a significant contraction in the breath of the golden formula, a combination of events which has considerably extended the scope of potential liability for industrial participants in industrial action” The following paper will address the accuracy of the above statement. There was a massive change in the course of law in UK regarding the trade union’s capacity for taking industrial action in the period 1979-97. It was considered as the prime time for labor union as it gained strength and high memberships. There were conservatives who wanted to curtail the growing power of the trade and labor unions. Although initially the conservatives had a soft approach regarding this issue but later they wanted to bring back the norms from the Industrial Act 1971 which was considered as ill-fated in UK. The industries felt the taste of insecurity with the rise in Trade Unions and their power and were forced to change their soft approach on the issue. There was a constant revision process of Employment Act in UK with the immunization of the Trade Unions from 1980-90. In UK since 1979, there were six revisions of Employment Act took place in years, 1980, 1982, 1984, 1988, 1989, 1990. These revisions were followed by Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act or (TULR(C)A) in 1992, the Trade Union Reform And Employment Rights Act (TURERA) in 1993 and Employment Rights Act on 1996.1 These regulations and acts provided direct and indirect support in making the Trade Unions powerful in UK. These rights increased the protection of individuals from the dictating forces of the employers. The employers used to dictate the employees previously on issues of joining the trade unions which influenced an individual’s decision making.2 There are some general issues which arise out of these regulations like the effects of these changes on the capacity of the Trade Unions in taking industrial actions and the commitment of economic torts by taking these actions. These issues are the subject of discussions in whole of UK and there are different view points regarding this. Commitment of Economic Torts The Economic Torts provide protection from interference in someone’s business and trade. It does not give provision to any individual to hamper others’ business or trade by creating nuisance. In the English Common Law there was no recognition of right to strike or organize any strike in UK. If there was any strike in the industries then the labors were withdrawn from work for indefinite period which prevented them from taking such aggressive step against the industries in UK. It was considered as the breach of contract by the employees and workers if they organize or support any industrial strike. The official or unofficial trade union leaders, who organize the industrial strikes were considered to be committing an economic tort by breaching their official employment contract and were subject to suspension from work. However, there was little liberty given to organizing strikes on behalf of statutory defenses which are against the Economic torts of UK under the Trade Dispute Acts. Later in the 80s these statutory defenses were amended and further amendment and consolidation occurred in TULRC Ac in 1992.3 According to the House of Lords, the unions should be responsible in tort for influencing and encouraging the workers to organize a strike against their employers for increasing their wages. This exasperated the workers and resulted in the formation of British Labor Party and the Trade Disputes Act. Later torts were used against the unions for conspiracy and intervention in commercial business and contracts.4 These steps triggered the sentiments of the workers and are responsible for the commitments of economic torts in UK. The Government and the regulatory bodies thought, this step might discourage the growth of trade unions in the country and break their agendas against the employers but it united them to form the British Labor Party. Golden Formula The golden formula for trade union for taking industrial action was established in UK by the Trades Dispute Act in 1906 and which says that there should be legal immunity for the trade unions if their industrial actions are found to be the reflection or result of a certain trade dispute in the industry. That is there will be no legal action against the trade unions if their industrial actions are found to be under severe pressure or trade dispute in the industry. Trade dispute comprises of all those actions taken by the employer against an employee like issues over the employment contract, terms and conditions specified in contract, allocation of work, dismissal, union membership, etc.5 This measure was taken to end the unfair exploitation of workers by the employers and reduce the trade disputes. Thus the establishment of Golden Formula is a major step in the growth of Trade Union in UK. Section 219 of TULR(C) Act 1992 This section establishes the immunities for the employees against certain types and forms of industrial actions against trade disputes. It states that, “in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute”6 the steps taken are not chargeable in the court, as these steps are taken on self-defensive actions and are not directly responsible in breach of employment contract. This section supported and defends the actions of the trade unions but it required lots of tests before it was established. The first test that came up over this issue was to determine the actual trade disputes which will be liable in industrial action and statutory immunity. Under section 244, the trade dispute comprises of all those actions taken by the employer against an employee like issues over the employment contract, terms and conditions specified in contract, allocation of work, dismissal, union membership, etc. but the disputes over future terms will not be considered. If any strike happens under the course of these above stated disputes the according to section 219, the employees can’t be dismissed from work by the employer. A strike can be called “official” if it’s been organized by any employee who is a member of an authorized trade union and the decision of strike was made by the higher officials of the trade union. If the actions are found to be unofficial then individuals responsible for these actions will not get any benefit of section 219 and will be liable to economic tort and can be dismissed from work.7 Conclusion It can be seen that there was an enormous growth in the provision of immunities in industrial actions by the trade unions in UK in the last three decades which increased the scope of economic torts in the industrial sector. This surely had a direct effect on the increasing number of individuals liable to economic tort for taking industrial action in UK. The privileges in section 219 are being misused to large extent which had resulted in the extension of scope of economic tort in industrial action in UK. The above discussion supported the fact expressed by Professor Deborah Lockton in his book and hence the initial statement. The supportive Employment Rights Acts have provided enough scope for the employees and workers in UK to be liable for economic tort in industrial actions. Reference 1. Lockton. D, (2005), Trade unions and industrial actions, Employment Law, Routledge Cavendish. Available at: http://books.google.co.in/books?id=RQDqhqWa2eQC&pg=PA229&dq=THE+LAW+OF+INDUSTRIAL+ACTION+Deborah+Lockton&source=gbs_toc_r&cad=7#v=onepage&q=&f=false (accessed on December 17, 2009) 2. Elias.P, Ewing.K, (November 1982), Economic Torts and Labour Law: Old principles and new liabilities, Cambridge Law journal, 41(2). Available at: http://www.jstor.org/pss/4506460 (accessed on December 17, 2009) 3. Industrial Law Journal (December 2007), Economic tort liability in labour disputes: The potential impact of the House of Lords’ decision in OBG Ltd v Allan, Oxford Journal, 36(4). Available at: http://ilj.oxfordjournals.org/cgi/pdf_extract/36/4/468 (accessed on December 17, 2009) 4. Economic Torts, (2009), Torts, Absolute Astronomy.com. Available at: http://www.absoluteastronomy.com/topics/Tort (accessed on December 17, 2009) 5. Business Management, (n.d), Golden Formula: trade union, industrial action, immunity, trade dispute, jrank.org. Available at: http://www.jrank.org/business/pages/671/golden-formula.html (accessed on December 17, 2009) 6. Trade Union and Labour Relations (Consolidation) Act, (1992), Restrictions of offence of conspiracy: England and Wales, Office of Public Sector Information. Available at: http://www.opsi.gov.uk/acts/acts1992/ukpga_19920052_en_14 (accessed on December 17, 2009) 7. Law and trade disputes (July 31, 2008), Statutory immunities, Local Government Employers. Available at: http://www.lge.gov.uk/lge/core/page.do?pageId=119715 (accessed on December 17, 2009) Read More

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Industrial Action in the UK

The Analysis of the Freedom of Association

Trade unions and their members had a tough time carrying out their activities especially Industrial Action in the UK owing to stringent regulations that gave employers an opportunity to frustrate collective bargaining.... Allowing employers to offer financial advances to their employees on the condition of dropping their rightful engagement in the collective bargain in the uk is a violation of trade unions and their members' rights.... It is no doubt that the ruling of the ECHR in the Wilson v United Kingdom case has serious implications on the labour laws in the uk (Ewing, 2003)....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

Industrial Relations Law

“Since 1980 industrial relations law in the uk has adopted an anti-trade union stance and has been too restrictive.... Partial access to the state through a voluntary system of industrial relations has, in the uk, sustained the historically embedded yet short-term interest of many employers.... More significantly, collective laissez-faire is functional because it is an institutional an embodiment of the process of particularization in the uk state....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

Industrial Relations Law in the UK

The paper "Industrial Relations Law in the uk " discusses that generally, the employment relations must have a strong connection with the performance standards so as to cater to a more generalized behavioural pattern where pay and work is concerned.... The categories in this paper will broadly include legal and sociological implications and issues of industrial law in the uk.... This revolution started in the uk due to its history of industrial development, where it has been hailed as an international pioneer of the industrial revolution....
11 Pages (2750 words) Essay

Industrial Action

The extent of industrial action : in the uk, official statistics on the use of industrial sanctions relate only to strikes.... In 2000 the number of working days lost in the uk was 499,00.... The political “voice” of unions in the U.... appears to be stronger than it is....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

UK Industrial Restrictions on Labour Relations

n the other hand, Trade Unions in the uk are prohibited from supporting acts that might construe an inducement to breach employment contract or performance of such duties as appertain to the agreement between individuals and their employers (Gladstone and Wheeler 1992, p.... It provides instances of industrial actions with a view to unravel how the uk government have always handles such conflicts.... Industrial Relations and the uk lawsContrary to common practice, the uk has demonstrated significant laxity in promoting exclusive protection of human rights as stipulated in the European Convention on Human Rights....
7 Pages (1750 words) Essay

Industrial Pollution

industrial pollution contributes to the greenhouse effect that results in climate change disrupting weather patterns resulting to widespread famine, and it is the leading cause of health and enviromental challenges affecting animals and plants resulting in ill health and even death.... hile conceding that the impacts of industrial pollution are very serious, it is not too late to take preventive actions....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Regulation of Industrial Relations in the UK

The following essay "Regulation of Industrial Relations in the uk" critically evaluates the view that the UK state has shifted from being the promoter of industrial relations through voluntarism to actively supporting some minimum standards within the employment contract.... The government or state's intervention has moved toward a more active role in regulating the relationship between employee and employer and working conditions in the uk.... The state's role is typically manifested by the passing of the law and the implementation of policies that impact how management, staff, and unions relate and by doing so regulate industrial relations Up to the 1950s, the uk state's role in industrial relations was characterized as involving minimum intervention (Kahn-Freund, 1969)....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

The Development of Role of the State in Employee Relations in the UK and South Korea

The paper 'The Development of Role of the State in Employee Relations in the uk and South Korea" is a great example of a management case study.... The paper 'The Development of Role of the State in Employee Relations in the uk and South Korea" is a great example of a management case study.... The paper 'The Development of Role of the State in Employee Relations in the uk and South Korea" is a great example of a management case study.... in the uk, the methods of employment can be categorized into two; employment or self-employment....
7 Pages (1750 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us