StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Crime and Ethical Standards - Assignment Example

Cite this document
Summary
A high end retailer reported that a woman left the store without paying for items she selected while shopping in the Misses Clothing Department.When Officer Marconi responded, he noticed a woman matching her description walking along the side of the road carrying what appeared to be clothing which he recognized as Mary Jones…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER98.7% of users find it useful
Crime and Ethical Standards
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Crime and Ethical Standards"

? Crime and Ethical Standards I. Case Background A high end retailer reported that a woman left the store without paying for items she selected while shopping in the Misses Clothing Department. When Officer Marconi responded, he noticed a woman matching her description walking along the side of the road carrying what appeared to be clothing which he recognized as Mary Jones. Mary Jones had been arrested several times before for public drunkenness, resisting arrest, possession of a controlled substance, felony larceny, and prostitution. The charge that can be lodged against Mary Jones is defined by San Diego Criminal Attorney’s office differentiated as it misdemeanor from felony as “crimes punishable by up to one year in local, county jail. Additionally, fines up to $1,000 can be ordered by the court. The most common types of misdemeanor offenses are D.U.I., petty theft, simple drug possession, and most domestic violence. While jail is a distinct possibility, other more likely outcomes can include counseling and/or work service” (2007).  Shoplifting or getting clothes from a store without paying as what Mary Jane did falls under this category. How might societal factors have influenced this suspect's crimes? Judging from the available facts stated in the case, Mary Jones may also be a victim of circumstances and in fact, she may not be in full control of her faculties when she allegedly enter the store and shoplift. This was made clear to Officer Marconi when he interviewed her recognizing she was under the influence of drugs that he had to discontinue the and requested emergency medical services. It would also be difficult to state with certainty what led to her present state of being disheveled dirty and drug dependent. One can only speculate that societal factors such as personal problems may have driven her to alcohol and drug abuse and to finance her dependency, she resorted to prostitution and larceny. II. How the purpose of government and the social contract might protect the rights (e.g., safety and security) of the suspect in this case. Mary Jones is not only a suspect but also a victim as well and the government’s social contract principle can hold this thesis. As a suspect, she is entitled to the regular due process and representation of a legal counsel in case charges will be pressed against her as provided in the Constitution. This will provide the opportunity to contest the larceny charge to misdemeanor because shoplifting can be considered as petty theft and therefore would fall under the category of misdemeanor. This would help her because in the state of California, misdemeanor charges may have the outcome of rehabilitating her through therapy and other professional help. In addition, the social burden of felony of having difficulty finding a job once charged will also be avoided thus not totally shutting down the opportunities for Mary Jones to lead a new life. Abiding by the social contract theory principle, she would also be considered as a victim considering her present state which could be considered as a “broken woman” and therefore would need more than due process and legal counsel as expressed in Rawl’s theory of justice as a pretext of a social contract. Rawl’s theory of justice as a social contract states that society has an obligation to help other members of society who are in need and clearly (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy nd), Mary Jones needs help. Incarcerating will not help her but will only aggravate her situation. She needs reformatory institution such as rehabilitation center more than the prison and this is a probable outcome for people who committed misdemeanors in the state of California (San Diego Criminal Attorney, 2007). III. Compare the various roles Officer Marconi must play in this case. Officer Marconi must go beyond the role of traditional role of law enforcement which is policing the community. In the case of Mary Jones, he must also play the role of psychologist and to a certain extent as a friend by understanding and assessing her situation. Relying on one role as police officer would not be responsive because it might make him more aggressive also when Mary Jones run at the sight of him taking it as resisting arrest and would not really help the situation. IV. Analyze how a law enforcement officer's actions might be influenced if he or she is arresting an "unsympathetic suspect or victim The officer’s action may already be “framed” based on previous experience on dealing with the suspect. In the case of Officer Marconi, he already anticipated that Mary Jones will run at the sight of him and that she will later be aggressive with him which turned out to be right. In a way this could be good because this will prepare the Officer with what to expect with the suspect. V. Conclusion Maintaining ethical standards while enforcing the law and especially while dealing with various kind of people can be difficult. It requires a sharp assessment and delicate balancing act to come up with the sound judgment on how to deal with a suspect. In the case of Officer Marconi, he subscribed more to Rawl’s theory of justice in dealing with Mary Jones than being solely a policeman. When it was made clear to him that the suspect was not in her right frame of mind, he called for professional medical help instead of incarcerating her. The decision was correct, knowing that sending her in prison will only aggravate her situation. In addition, charging her with felony would burden Mary Jones if she will later change her ways because people who are charged with felony will have difficulty getting jobs (Shouse Law Group, 2012) while charging her with misdemeanor may have the outcome of sending her to therapies and other professional help which could help her rehabilitate herself. References San Diego Criminal Attorney (2007). Felony vs. Misdemeanors.Retrieved from http://www.sandiegocrimedefense.com/felony-misdemeanor-charges.html Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (nd). John Rawls. Retrieved from http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/rawls/ Shouse Law Group (2012). Reducing Felony Convictions to Misdemeanors: Penal Code 17(b) PC. Retrieved from http://www.shouselaw.com/reducing-felony-to-misdmeanor.html Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Crime and Ethical Standards Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Retrieved de https://studentshare.org/law/1470421-crime-and-ethical-standards
(Crime and Ethical Standards Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
https://studentshare.org/law/1470421-crime-and-ethical-standards.
“Crime and Ethical Standards Assignment Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/law/1470421-crime-and-ethical-standards.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Crime and Ethical Standards

Ethical Issues in Counselling Practice

Ethical Codes and Laws Ethical codes differ from laws in the respect that ethical codes are frameworks followed by counselors during practice, whereas laws are the implementation of set minimum socially acceptable standards by the government (Grant, 2009).... ethical Issues in Counseling Every profession has its codes and morals which ethicality of behaviour and decision.... Counseling also has specific codes which are not only intended to provide a standard of conduct to guide the counselors, but also to help counselors to choose and arrive at ethical actions and decisions (APA, 2010)....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Company's Ethical Code of Conduct for the Smooth Running of Its Business

Now questions might arise concerning what should be the moral standards of a person or organization.... Moral standards are different for different situations.... It should be given more priority than any other standards related to an organization, which includes self interest even.... The guidelines specified for setting moral standards are the basic conventional norms against killing, lying, stealing, cheating etc.... There is no rulebook regarding the ethical & moral standards because it's something which is very obviously expected from a person, as moral is a part of human nature & they are expected to apply it when doing business with other individuals....
12 Pages (3000 words) Assignment

Ethics Governing Cyber Laws

These moral standards vary from one culture to another and are often not mandated.... ethical behavior consists of conducting yourself according to principals of right and wrong.... ethical behavior consists of "fair and honest behavior" (Concise Oxford English Dictionary, 2006).... Because ethical behavior varies from one culture to another it is hard to legislate this behavior as wrong or right....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Banking Industry Meltdown: The Ethical and Financial Risks of Derivatives

Banking industry has often been This is a discussion on the ethical perspectives on the banking industry meltdown.... All employees within the banking industry have an ethical responsibility for making good business decisions.... Since the ultimate course, according to ethical teleology, depends on the present course of action, the involved business professionals need to articulate their course of action such that it yields good results.... This is the principal of ethical teleology....
4 Pages (1000 words) Case Study

Ethics In Criminal Justice

Normative ethics concerns standards of behavior and conduct.... It is also crucial to understand that ethics in criminal justice involves determining right and wrong in terms of human standards.... crime relates to social conditions and circumstances through its subjectivity to the criminal justice system and the law.... The social context of criminal justice ethics understands the necessity for recognizing criminals, not after the crime, but also through the comprehension of the environment and conditions that force people into crime....
5 Pages (1250 words) Research Paper

Ethical And Moral Dilemma Case Studies

The paper "ethical And Moral Dilemma Case Studies" describes what a panel of persons sit and consider whether a person in offense and serving in prison should be released having served the minimum term prescribed and be monitored under parole explains a 'parole board'.... The ethical support o such reasoning would be based on the fact that crime towards humanity is always unethical.... This paper postulates that Linda would assume the call by the dispatcher to concentrate on the drug crime as it is an equal crime as the burglary is....
9 Pages (2250 words) Case Study

What Do We Mean by Unethical Business Practices

The paper "What Do We Mean by Unethical Business Practices?... concerns the critical analysis of the concept of unethical business practices.... The essay explains the meaning of ethics so as to gain a clear understanding of what unethical business practices mean with real-life examples.... hellip; Some of the activities that can be characterized as unethical business practices include the following: resorting to dishonesty or deception, distortion of facts to mislead or confuse the consumers, greed to amass excessive wealth, lack of transparency, harming the environment for financial gains, lack of privacy as well as sexual discrimination....
8 Pages (2000 words) Essay

The Ethical Issues of Information Security

… The paper "The ethical Issues of Information Security " is a good example of a term paper on information technology.... Information security is a very sensitive issue because of the ethical issues that are raised as areas of concern.... The paper "The ethical Issues of Information Security " is a good example of a term paper on information technology.... Information security is a very sensitive issue because of the ethical issues that are raised as areas of concern....
8 Pages (2000 words) Term Paper
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us