StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Affluenza: The new illness in Australia - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
In the contemporary scenario, the perception of the Australian masses as to the amount of money that they need to live a fulfilled life is based less on the historical and international realities and more on their innate beliefs and desires. Australians associate happiness with affluence, which is not necessarily true. …
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.1% of users find it useful
Affluenza: The new illness in Australia
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Affluenza: The new illness in Australia"

 ‘Affluenza: The new illness in Australia?’ INTRODUCTION In the contemporary scenario, the perception of the Australian masses as to the amount of money that they need to live a fulfilled life is based less on the historical and international realities and more on their innate beliefs and desires. Australians associate happiness with affluence, which is not necessarily true. According to Clive Hamilton, more and more Australian families are attributing happiness to the possession of material entities. In the article ‘Affluenza: The new illness in Australia?’ published in Brisbane Line on 23 July 2005, Hamilton systematically intends to dissect this new social phenomenon. Though the article intends to support premises by quoting valid data, it fails to take into cognizance some basic realities of life. SUMMARY In ‘Affluenza: The new illness in Australia?’, Hamilton elaborates on the sense of insufficiency and discontent prevalent in the Australians, irrespective of the fact that not only Australia happens to be one of the richest countries in the world, but the citizens of Australia enjoy incomes and a life style that is far more sumptuous as compared to the people residing in other nations. In the start, Hamilton takes on the fact that the modern Australians tend to associate happiness with material attributes. Still, they happen to be generally discontented in a scenario in which all the available historical and international facts indicate that they are richer then their predecessors. The author then argues that unlike the days of the yore when material possessions were associated with basic needs and requirements, the contemporary Australians endow material entities like gadgets and cars with personal status and well-being. The appliances and gadgets are getting ultra-savvy and the sellers are taking advantage of the innate shortcomings and needs of the people to encourage them to buy latest goods. Hamilton emphatically deplores the fact that this craze for affluence and material goods is eating into the vital Australian attributes like a fundamental sense of equality, community spirit and general gregariousness. According to Hamilton, the modern Australians are more self centred and have little ability to extend their concern beyond personal comfort and desires. Under such circumstances, the negative feelings like jealousy, selfishness and discontent are rather encouraged and exploited by the vendors of material goods. As per Hamilton, the new trend of pursuing affluence at the cost of other values is not what the real Australian Civilization is all about. CRITIQUE One positive aspect of Hamilton’s article is that it supports the premises made by the writer with relevant and appropriate data. First Hamilton argues that the innate aspirations of the Australians often fail to match their real financial achievements. Once Hamilton makes this assertion, he supports his argument by quoting the related data showing that people often intrinsically correlate their financial aspirations with the financial statues of others instead of their actual requirements. For example, Hamilton states that the contemporary Australians tend to be more affluent as far as their possessions are concerned. Then he goes on to support this premise by presenting the historical data, which amply proves that the premises of Australian masses are more spacious and well equipped then those of their predecessors. In this context, Hamilton definitely intends to elaborate on the repercussions of Affluenza, as John de Graff does in his book ‘Affluenza’. He comes down on materialism in the same vein as Tim Kasser does in his book ‘The High Price of Materialism’. Hamilton also quotes data gathered from the Australian gadgets markets to reveal how the market forces play on the discontent of the Australians to make them buy modern gadgets and accessories. Despite presenting the real data, Hamilton’s article is not convincing because he fails to support his assertions with the apt scientific and psychological facts. The most obvious weakness of this article is that though Hamilton presents ample data, he mostly tries to interpret the factual evidence in the light of his personal beliefs and intentions. Hamilton seems to be biased in his interpretations of data as Less does in the article ‘Are we all Suffering from Affluenza?’ He seems to be bent on using the available data to detest consumption as Suzie does in the article ‘Affluenza: Is there a Cure?’ For example, Hamilton says that a majority of the Australians believe that they do not afford to buy everything they need and supports this conclusion with the results of the Newspoll survey. In the next step, Hamilton twists these facts to conclude that Australians believe that their incomes are inadequate. Now, it is a simple fact that no matter how rich a person is, there always exist some things that are beyond one’s budget. This does not mean that the person necessarily feels discontented or inadequate. In fact, many people believe that aspirations and desires to some extent encourage and motivate a person to perform well. Hamilton also argues that though the modern Australians have more spacious and well-equipped homes, they seem to be discontented and bolsters his argument with relevant data. Now, access to better and modern living conditions does not necessarily means that people are getting more covetous. The other weakness in Hamilton’s claims is that they are not backed by appropriate scientific and psychological evidence, a mistake committed by many other astute writers like Thane. For example, Hamilton states that the levels of desires of the Australians are continually on the rise due to the availability of the state of the art gadgets. It is a commonsensical fact that with each successive year, manufacturers do come out with gadgets that are more sophisticated and naturally, people prefer to buy the latest models. This in no way proves that the levels of desire of the masses are soaring unexceptionally. Besides, Hamilton fails to back this claim with any relevant scientific or psychological study. Hamilton argues that the advent of latest and costly barbeques has deteriorated the Australian social values. Again, he fails to present any relevant psychological study or research to support this premise. Hamilton also states that people buy latest gadgets and cars because of their insecurity and vanity, without quoting any factual or psychological evidence. Thus, Hamilton seems to be biased in the conclusions he made and fails to support them with some scientific evidence, unlike Oliver does in his article ‘Infected by affluenza’ published in the Guardian on 24 January 2007. CONCLUSION In conclusion, Hamilton appears to be misusing the available data to gain acceptance for his personal beliefs. In addition, Hamilton has made baseless and vague comments about the mentality and social values of the Australians, without backing them with the latest sociological or psychological studies. It is very absurd to comment on the propensities of an entire nation, without presenting any credible evidence. Works Cited Graff, John de. Affluenza. New York: Berrett-Koehler Publishers, 2002. James, Oliver. “Infected by Affluenza”. The Guardian. 24 January 2997. 4-5 Kasser, Tim. The High Price of Materialism. New York: The MIT Press, 2003. Less, C. “Are we all suffering from affluenza?” The Ethical Examiner. Spring 2008, 2-6. Suzie, Brown. “Affluenza: Is there a Cure?” Habitat Australia. August 2005. 7-8. Thane, Stenner. “Financial facts and money matters: Finding the cure for affluenza”. Institute of Chartered Accountants of British Columbia. 2003, HighBeam Research. 7 Nov. 2009 Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Affluenza: The new illness in Australia Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words”, n.d.)
Affluenza: The new illness in Australia Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 words. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1559482-affluenza-the-new-illness-in-australia
(Affluenza: The New Illness in Australia Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words)
Affluenza: The New Illness in Australia Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1559482-affluenza-the-new-illness-in-australia.
“Affluenza: The New Illness in Australia Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 1000 Words”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/health-sciences-medicine/1559482-affluenza-the-new-illness-in-australia.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Affluenza: The new illness in Australia

WHO considers vaccination to be a primary intervention in the preventation of disease and promotion of wellbeing

Immunology refers to study of molecules, cells organs and systems, which facilitate identification and disposal of foreign materials.... Immunology commences as a component of microbiology; in fact, this is a study of infections illnesses to which the human body responds to have a significant role in establishment of immunology (WHO, 2012)....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Epidemiology: H1N1 Virus

Epidemiology Name: Institution: Course: Tutor: Date: Introduction H1N1 virus has been one of the most studied in australia, this is partly because of the risk that it poses to the citizens and the levels of hospitalization associated with the disease especially among people who had other illnesses and medical complications.... Before the vaccine for the disease was available in June 2009, there was widespread community transmission in australia where the public health authorities were more concerned about protecting the people who were at greatest risk of sever illness; these included, expectant mothers, individuals suffering from obesity; people with chronic medical conditions such as heart, lung and kidney diseases; and indigenous people (Dominguez-Cherit et al, 2009; Morgan et al, 2010)....
10 Pages (2500 words) Essay

The Search for Better Health

In man's search for better prevention and cure for previously unstoppable diseases, scientists and researchers peered into the specific nature of the causal agents of diseases for the development of appropriate medicine.... There was remarkable success in treating minor illnesses using chemicals and surgical operations but some were noted to cause recurrent epidemics but were in fact preventable....
12 Pages (3000 words) Essay

Colonization Impact on Aboriginal's Health

Aboriginal people are the natives of australia, who believe in cultures and spirituality.... But in 1788 Europeans invaded their world and lead to the colonization of their untouched paradise and brought disorder, disharmony and a new western systems of legislature, enactment, principle, enforcement, courts and incarceration....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Development of a Policy Document to Prevent the Spread of the Influenza among the Clinical Staff

This paper attempts to develop a policy document for the steps to be taken to during an influenza pandemic to prevent the spread of the infection to clinical staff caring for infected patients in the wards of a health care environment.... Several reasons prompt the decision on the development.... hellip; According to the discussion during influenza pandemic individuals falling ill commonly seek assistance from the health care provider that provides their normal health care needs....
6 Pages (1500 words) Essay

Health Promotion Approches Used in the National Prevention Summit 2008

However,… is worth noting that the resolutions made on this platform for prevention have been so far revised and refined to align them with the australia 2020 Summit and the working programs being carried out by National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission together with the National Those who participated in the National Prevention Summit did consent to a number of underlying key principles and various steps that were meant for policy development and the delivery of prevention program....
9 Pages (2250 words) Essay

Prevention of diseases

This will reduce the common cases of the emergence of new chronic illness.... hellip; Chronic illness, environmental pollution, domestic violence has resulted in the emergence of various diseases that have claimed the lives of many people.... A lot of research has been done in the field of health sciences which has helped in reducing death rates that occur due to illness such as H1N1 that claimed the lives of many individuals in 2009.... new methods should be employed to help in proper disposal of waste materials (Pellow, 2006: p....
9 Pages (2250 words) Assignment

Beneficial Direction of the Welfare State from the Perspective of Poverty Removal in Australia

"Beneficial Direction of the Welfare State from the Perspective of Poverty Removal in australia" paper argues that the Australian welfare state has been unable to provide benefits adequate to offset the inequalities due to the principle of deservingness determining the extent of benefits received.... As will be shown, though the history of poverty in australia justifies active state intervention in the protection of social rights, the present manifestation of the regime is based on certain fundamentals that require revision in order to serve effectively for the purpose of poverty alleviation....
7 Pages (1750 words) Coursework
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us