StudentShare
Contact Us
Sign In / Sign Up for FREE
Search
Go to advanced search...
Free

Why There Is No Southern Problem - on Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the EU - Essay Example

Cite this document
Summary
The paper "Why There Is No Southern Problem - on Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the EU" considers the ‘southern problem’ as “Mediterranean syndrome” due to various reasons which include deficiency in the administrative capacities and absence of well-structured technical expertise…
Download full paper File format: .doc, available for editing
GRAB THE BEST PAPER93.7% of users find it useful
Why There Is No Southern Problem - on Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the EU
Read Text Preview

Extract of sample "Why There Is No Southern Problem - on Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the EU"

?Analytical Paper about the Article "Why There Is No 'Southern Problem'. On Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the European Union" Table of Contents Introduction 3 Thesis Statement 3 A Brief Analysis of the Argument 4 Use of Evidence to Support the Argument 5 Conclusion 8 Work Cited 9 Introduction Non-adherence with European Union (EU) based environmental laws has been often considered to be a ‘southern problem’. The problem generally occurred due to the changing features as well as the systemic deficiencies in the political along with administrative institutions belonging to the different southern member provinces of EU. Moreover, the different aspects which include lack of a civic culture, managerial capacity, increased level of corruption and most importantly party-dominated legislative procedures are strongly believed to be the major causes of non-compliance with EU based environmental laws (Borzel, “Why There Is No ‘Southern Problem’. On Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the European Union”). Thesis Statement This discussion intends to identify the argument which is made by the author relating to the article that is principally based upon the non-compliance with the EU based environmental laws. Moreover, the evidences which are used by the author in supporting the argument will be discussed. Various significant aspects which comprise the judgment about the evidence, whether, it is strong or weak and the grounds of agreeing or not agreeing with the argument will also be portrayed in the discussion. A Brief Analysis of the Argument In relation to the article, it has been viewed that the author made several arguments focusing upon the reality that non-adherence with the environmental laws belonging to EU is considered to be a ‘southern problem’. The difficulty regarding protecting the environment is considered to be a ‘southern problem’ as certain southern member provinces of EU strongly believed that they were incapable to implement the EU environmental law effectively. The author considered the ‘southern problem’ as the “Mediterranean syndrome” in his article due to a broad assortment of reasons. According to the author, the problem generally occurred due to the weaker role performed by the Ministry of the Environment belonging to the different southern provinces of EU. Moreover, the author also argued that the problem took place due to shortage in the administrative capacities for effectually implementing EU based environmental policies. It has been viewed in the article that the southern member provinces of EU did not possess adequate technical know-how, potential working staffs and well-structured infrastructures for applying as well as enforcing EU environmental based legislative policies. The author suggested that the southern member provinces belonging to EU should implement environmental policies competently for the purpose of developing their financial progression, increasing economic interests and most significantly generating employment. The effective execution of the EU environmental schemes or policies would ultimately promote the economic advancement of the different southern member provinces belonging to EU as well as enhance their environmental quality level by a greater extent. The author identified a significant reason which eventually restricted the southern member provinces of EU to implement EU environmental based policies effectively. The significant reason was that the southern member provinces belonging to EU possessed the political systems which were conventionally dominated by clientelism, disrespect and patronage for the public authority. On the basis of the article, the author argued that there lays significant disparities in meeting with the EU environmental laws throughout the different European member provinces which cannot be escorted by a simple north-south separation. The other argument which is made by the author in the article is that the relative study of the execution of the different environmental policies belonging to EU particularly in Spain and Germany revealed that compliance can differ across various policies within one country. The author also made the argument in the article affirming that the problems relating to compliance can be expected if there lies significant ‘misfit’ between the policies of the EU and a corresponding national policy. Amongst the aforementioned arguments which were made by the author in the article, the argument regarding policy misfit between a corresponding national policy and an EU policy is one of the essential causes of non-compliance, is quite an interesting one (Borzel, “Why There Is No ‘Southern Problem’. On Environmental Leaders And Laggards In The European Union”). Use of Evidence to Support the Argument The author used significant evidences in order to support the argument that the feature of policy misfit is an essential reason of non-compliance which ultimately raises crucial problems. According to the author, the difficulties relating to compliance can be anticipated if there lies a misfit between the EU environmental policies and a corresponding national policy. In supporting the argument, the author used the evidence of external and domestic pressure for adaptation. From the perspective of external pressure for adaptation, it can be presumed that the execution and the compliance difficulties generally take place if the policies belonging to EU form the basis of pressure for adaptation. It has been apparently observed that more the policies belonging to EU opposes any corresponding policies at national level, the higher the requirement for a member state of EU to adapt legal as well as a managerial structures. These legal and the managerial structures involve huge costs and thus cause the problem of non-compliance. The policy misfit which causes non-compliance relating to external adaptation pressure can be measured by contrasting the corresponding national policies with an EU policy with regard to their implementation of policy instruments, policy standards and problem-solving approaches. Conversely, it can be believed that policy misfit which causes non-compliance relating to domestic pressure can be exercised or measured through the execution of different channels which include the political parties, various environmental organizations and powerful interest groups. These channels ultimately draw attention of the public opinions regarding the events of non-compliance with the environmental legislation belonging to EU. On the basis of the aforesaid evidences used by the author in the article, it has generated an important hypothesis affirming that the greater the adaptation pressure along with a low domestic mobilization level, the more likely the occurrence of non-compliance. Thus, it can be stated that non-compliances can occur due to policy misfit by taking into concern the practical implications of both external and domestic adaptation pressures (Borzel, “Why There Is No ‘Southern Problem’. On Environmental Leaders And Laggards In The European Union”). The observed evidences can be considered to be quite strong as they pointed out the reality that policy misfits are among the crucial reasons for causing compliance problem. The origin of the compliance problem due to the result of significant policy misfit concerning the external and domestic pressure for adaptation had ultimately made the evidence more strong. The argument regarding policy misfit which is considered to be one of the leading causes for occurrence of non-compliances can be agreed by a greater extent. This argument can be agreed because the policy misfit authentically generates the problem of compliance with EU policy measures. This is due to the reason of prevailing incompatibilities between the various policy instruments in different member states of EU. Besides, the EU member states are not able to influence the various environmental norms of EU due to the presence of incompatibility in their policy directives (Borzel, “Why There Is No ‘Southern Problem’. On Environmental Leaders And Laggards In The European Union”). Conclusion The author considered the ‘southern problem’ as “Mediterranean syndrome” due to various reasons which include deficiency in the administrative capacities and absence of well-structured technical expertise among others. The evidences which are used by the author in the article that include the aspect of external as well as domestic pressure for adaptation explicitly indicated that there would be increased problem of compliance if a particular EU policy does not fit in managerial as well as in legal structures. It is the different member states of EU that have to discard the incompatibilities which are present in their respective policy instruments and styles for minimizing the problem of non-compliance by a considerable level. Work Cited Borzel, Tanja A. “Why There Is No ‘Southern Problem’. On Environmental Leaders And Laggards In The European Union”. Journal of European Public Policy 7:1 (2000): 141-162. Print. Read More
Cite this document
  • APA
  • MLA
  • CHICAGO
(“Analytical Paper about the article Why there is no 'southern problem' Essay”, n.d.)
Analytical Paper about the article Why there is no 'southern problem' Essay. Retrieved from https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1458795-analytical-paper-about-the-article-why-there-is-no
(Analytical Paper about the Article Why There Is No 'Southern problem' Essay)
Analytical Paper about the Article Why There Is No 'Southern problem' Essay. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1458795-analytical-paper-about-the-article-why-there-is-no.
“Analytical Paper about the Article Why There Is No 'Southern problem' Essay”, n.d. https://studentshare.org/environmental-studies/1458795-analytical-paper-about-the-article-why-there-is-no.
  • Cited: 0 times

CHECK THESE SAMPLES OF Why There Is No Southern Problem - on Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the EU

H. Rider Haggard's King Solomon's Mines

Book Review: King Solomon's Mines H.... Rider Haggard wrote sixty-four pieces of literature, fiction and non-fiction, in his life (Berresford Ellis, 2) but the one for which he is most remembered is the 1885 novel King Solomon's Mines.... Although the idea of the 'Lost World' in literature can be traced much further back than Haggard's work, King Solomon's Mines is often hailed as the first “lost world adventure” (Foxwell, 295) and as such has always been extremely popular – not only has it never been out of print, but it ran to thirteen editions in the United States in its first year alone (Kaufman, 163)....
3 Pages (750 words) Book Report/Review

A Gentleman in Haggard's Time

The description of a gentleman in Haggard's volume, King Solomon's Mines is amongst the most prominent themes that this volume intends to explore.... The volume's setting is during an epoch when the British dominion was enlarging across the earth.... ... ... ... Moreover, the volume handles topics on racial supremacy and progress of customs with regard to the descriptions of masculinity confronting the English man....
3 Pages (750 words) Research Paper

Burger King and Innovation

In the paper 'Burger King and Innovation' the author tries to gain a better insight towards consumer preferences and consumer behaviour, go thorough information regarding the concept of innovation, its theories and empirical evidence to confirm the effectiveness of innovative strategies.... ... ... ...
57 Pages (14250 words) Essay

Environmental Leaders and Laggards in the European Union

This paper 'environmental leaders and laggards in the European Union' intends to identify the argument which is made relating to the article that is principally based upon the non-compliance with the EU based environmental laws.... The effective execution of the eu environmental schemes or policies would ultimately promote the economic advancement of the different southern member provinces belonging to EU as well as enhance their environmental quality level by a greater extent....
5 Pages (1250 words) Essay

Strategic Analysis of a Network Rail

The author in this study "Strategic Analysis of a Network Rail" has selected Network Rail as the sample organization in order to understand how the company has performed different strategic initiatives in the past five years for the purpose of addressing pertinent strategic issues.... ... ... ... From an academic perspective, this essay will be written in response to a Business Strategy coursework requirement as part of Robert Gordon University's BA Business Management program, but from business knowledge perspective; this essay will help the researcher to validate Exploring Strategy Model of Johnson, Whittington and Scholes (2011) in the real-world business scenario....
15 Pages (3750 words) Case Study

Gender inequality in the workplace: Northern Ireland and Southern Ireland

Women in Northern Ireland suffer a problem of low payment.... In view of this, the article discusses the gender inequality in the Workplace in Northern and southern Ireland.... It has a negative implication to the members of the society as it hinders the development of the society....
4 Pages (1000 words) Article

Political Transitions in East and Southeast Asia

This research proposal "Political Transitions in East and Southeast Asia" describes democratic Transitions of Asian countries.... This paper outlines Democratic Transitions of South Korea, the contaminating waves of democratization, the role of civil society in Korea's democratization.... ... ... ...
16 Pages (4000 words) Research Proposal

The EU Environmental Policy and Why It Is a Success to Both the Environment and the Economy

The author of"the eu Environmental Policy and Why It Is a Success to Both the Environment and the Economy" paper assesses the degree to which he/she feels the European environmental policy has been a success.... The study of the effects of the eu environmental policy puts its focus on how the legislation output of the European Union is formally implemented in its Members States, as well as its consequences in terms of the European environment state.... Accordingly, little is known about the causal relationships between the condition of the European environment and the eu environmental policy....
17 Pages (4250 words) Case Study
sponsored ads
We use cookies to create the best experience for you. Keep on browsing if you are OK with that, or find out how to manage cookies.
Contact Us